Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Chassidic Thought
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Kabbalah & Jewish Mysticism » Chassidic Thought » Insights & Readings » By Naftali Silberberg » Two-Faced Honesty

Two-Faced Honesty

Hypocrisy is not always a bad thing

Honesty is a great virtue, but there are exceptions to this rule. Prayer is a prime example.

Reader Comments
Posted: Sep 23, 2008
strugglling with prayer
Saying "no" to a piece of cake is, for me, "a piece of cake." Responding immediately to the 6;15 alarm clock ringing-- no problem! Opening up a siddur to daven -- uh oh! So I'm willing to try and follow your advice about "indulging" my G-dly soul. You packaged it so well, it might just do the trick.

Keep up the good work...and Shana Tova, as well!
Posted By M.H., North Miami Beach/Jerusalem, Florida/Israel

Posted: Sep 23, 2008
I liked the article, it was very well written and very informative, but my only complaint is that he said only us Jews have a G-dly soul, I've always believed and have been taught that every human has these two souls. I don't think we exclusively have a G-dly nature, all humans do. And to think only we have a G-dly soul and a spiritual nature is foolish and destructive. I do believe there is a Jewish soul that makes us unique, but I defiantly wouldn't say we are the only ones with a G-dly soul. But maybe I misinterpreted what the rabbi meant when he said that.
Posted By Joel

Posted: Sep 23, 2008
Thanks, your message brings hope and life.
Posted By Dario

Posted: Sep 23, 2008
hypocrisy in prayer
thanx for helping make this year's prayers more open to me. you hit "my" problem on the nail head and, with this essay added to my machzor as a reminder, shul will be more meaningful.
Posted By tehila leah

Posted: Sep 23, 2008
Conclusion
Right on, Joel, I was taught that a non-Jew's Godly soul has the same first three parts as a Jew has, nefesh, ruach, neshama, but doesn't have the two others, chai and y'chida. Is it not possible for a non-Jew to connect to God when praying?
I haven't learned that much chassidus, but I'd like Rabbi Silberberg to address this problematic understanding.
This is an extremely sensitive area of mysticism that requires tremendous knowledge to explain correctly & appropriately.
Posted By Moishe , NY

Posted: Sep 24, 2008
Prayer
Thanks, Rabbi, for the reminder that nothing I do negates my prayer. I just love knowing that during prayer, my "G-dly soul's integrity is absolute." I also know for sure that prayer changes things.
Posted By Liz, Marietta, GA

Posted: Sep 25, 2008
once more I enjoyed Rabbi Silberbergs profound article.I was struck by the honesty of the words "two paths of self gratification...".I believe this article can be used as a text for study for it unlocks profound themes. K'siva V'chasima Tova.
Posted By Rabbi Mordechai Berger, melbourne, aus.

 


By Naftali Silberberg
Talking With G‑d
Energy Crisis
Are We Being True to Ourselves?
Hide 'n Go Seek Gone Awry
Do You Resent Being Told What To Do?
The Ultimate Employee
Two-Faced Honesty