Printed from chabad.org
All Departments
Jewish Holidays
TheRebbe.org
Jewish.TV - Video
Jewish Audio
News
Kabbalah Online
JewishWoman.org
Kids Zone

Can I serve roast chicken at the seder?

Can I serve roast chicken at the seder?

E-mail

Question:

Someone mentioned to me that we don't eat roast chicken by the seder meal. Is this correct? And if so, what is the reason for this injunction?

Answer:

In the times of the Holy Temple, the Paschal lamb was offered on the afternoon preceding the seder, and then consumed at the Seder. As per biblical directive (Exodus 12:9), the lamb was roasted whole over an open fire. We commemorate the Paschal offering by speaking about it during the Haggadah, and the shank bone on the Seder plate serves as a symbolic reminder of this biblical command that we are unable to observe today, in the absence of a Holy Temple.

We hope and pray that we will soon see the rebuilding of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem, at which time we will once again offer the Paschal offering. Until then, though, most communities do not serve roasted meat or poultry at the seder, so that it doesn't appear that we are trying to "replace" the Paschal lamb.1 Even those who would eat roasted meat or chicken during the meal would not eat an entire roasted lamb or kid.

Meat or poultry roasted in a pan should also be avoided--if it was cooked in its own juices and no other liquid was added.

Click here to find recipes for delicious Passover dishes. Enjoy!

Wishing you a joyous and liberating Passover!

All the best,

Rochel Chein for Chabad.org

FOOTNOTES
1. Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 346,1.
Mrs. Rochel Chein is a member of the chabad.org Ask the Rabbi team.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
E-mail
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
Sort By:
Discussion (18)
April 5, 2012
Sephardim
Some Sephardim eat lamb on Pesah. I am Sephardic and my mother made roasted lamb on Pesah and it was delicious. What if I am Sephardic and I become a Chabadnik? Do I abandon my Sephardic customs?
Anonymous
Plainview, New York
April 21, 2011
Another advocate for the Sepharadim
My family is Sephardic and we have roasted lamb shank at every seder. It is delicious and something everyone looks forward to all year, and I don't think it's right for you to discourage others from having that as well just because it's your minhag not to.
Yael
New York, NY
March 18, 2010
Can I serve chicken at Seder?
When I saw this question on your web site, my instinctive, immediate reaction was "What sort of crazy animal lover is this person?? With all the family and guests and little children who need to be served, who could possibly worry about serving their chickens too?"

I'm so tired from cleaning that it wasn't until I clicked on the question that I realized the actual meaning of the question. I apologize that I thought (even if just for a moment) that you were a little bit weird.

Wishing you a kosher and joyous holiday,
SB Petrack
Brookline, MA
April 4, 2009
How about for Sephardim???
What a surprise (note the sarcasm), Chabad presented the Ashkenazi opinion and minhag as halacha and ignored the actual halacha and minhag of Sephardim/Mizrachhim.
Anonymous
March 24, 2009
Roasted meat at Seder
This is a widespread custom; there are Mizrachi communities that do allow it. I suspect that your readership deserves a more correct rendering.
Justin
April 29, 2008
it's ok sorry to be rude
i am sorry if i sounded rude. also when understanding halacha u must realize the torah is only half the puzzle. there was an oral tradition as well, like in the torah it just make a sign on your arm. the oral tradation was that a sign meant tephllin for example.
Boris/baruch Tuman
cleveland, ohio
April 29, 2008
Re: Torah commandment
Thanks very much for clarifying regarding the sacrifices. After deeper study my wife and I found the same things you mentioned. That sacrificies were to be brought only to HaShem's altar. I apologize for "popping" off before I studied the entire matter. We were not raised in Torah and therefore have much catching up to do! We wish we were raised properly and/or could afford to be properly educated but we can only do the best we can. We thank you for this website of learning and being able to ask questions and get answers in a respectful manner. Barukh haShem! :-)
Anonymous
Maumee, OH
April 29, 2008
Reply to what about the Torah
What u said is not 100% accurate the holy temple was an upgrade, not anything new. the Mishkan was the original site that the sacrifices would take place. and so when it referred to roasted lamb it meant on the altar. The only time it was roasted but not on an altar was before it was constructed. however we can not use this logic to say hey since we don't have an altar means she should do it ourselves. big mistake: for the following reasons.
1. the commandment to roast it with no altar was a one time deal. G-d has told us no such thing today
2. attempting to give a sacrifice (that's what the roasted lamb was ) your self is paganism, in fact this is like the "bammot" often mentioned in the prophets. and it is not acceptable
3. if ur source and reason where correct then the rabbis (who know the torah and halacha more then anyone today) would have said so, but as u can see our tradition doesn't have it so the rabbis did not put it in.
And on your quote: it's out of context.
Boris/Baruch Tuman
Cleveland, ohio/ usa
April 19, 2008
what about the Torah?
The Torah tells us that Moshe and the Hebrews were commanded to have roasted lamb and to observe this festival throughout our generations. Shemot 12. This was before a temple ever stood or before we ever entered the land. Why does Jewish law say the opposite? HaShem is still in charge as far as my family is concerned regarding this or any other law. HaShem's Torah comes first, otherwise we are following man.
Anonymous
Maumee, OH
April 17, 2008
Thanks
Thank you, that cleared everything up. Have a great pesach!
Avraham
Show all comments