Contact Us

Women at War

Women at War


The hall was packed. This was no ordinary wedding, but the wedding of the daughter of one of Jerusalem’s most prominent families. Leaders in the still quiet and nonviolent rebellion against the Greeks, they were respected and loved by Jews throughout the Land of Israel. Not to mention that, as priests in the Temple, the family had been looked up to for generations.

Amidst the elegant flowers, soft music, and the conversations of the guests, the bride suddenly stood up, walked to the center of the room, placed her hand on her chest, and tore open her gown.

Shocked, angry, and embarrassed, her brothers rose to drag her from the room. But she stood firmly in place and addressed the room: “You who are so zealous that you would kill me, are not zealous enough to protect me from the hands of the Greek governor who will come here to assault me tonight.

“Did you not learn from Shimon and Levi, the brothers of Dinah, who, though only two men, killed the entire city of Shechem for her sake? Place your faith in the One Above, and He will help you.”

Her five brothers declared their willingness to go to war, and were answered by a voice emanating from the Holy of Holies promising victory.

In her eyes it was a story of the struggle for political freedom The story of the Maccabees’ brave revolt is a familiar one not only to Jews but to most non-Jews as well. I can still remember my second-grade music teacher in public school giving a brief account of the miracle of the oil before teaching the whole class “Rock of Ages.” What was left out of her account were all the details about what the Jews were really fighting for. In her eyes it was a story of the struggle for political freedom, and fit in quite nicely with news accounts of Sakharov, Mandela, and others struggling for personal and national liberty.

As I grew older and became more involved with Judaism and the Jewish community, details seeped in. Initially, the Greeks treated the Jews with greater respect than they had treated other peoples they conquered. Alexander the Great had seen the High Priest, Shimon the Righteous, in a dream, and when Shimon went out to meet his approaching army, Alexander knelt before him and pledged never to harm Jerusalem or the Holy Temple.

Years passed. Alexander and Shimon the Righteous both passed away. Some Jews became quite infatuated with Greek culture. But the more they imitated the Greeks, the less respect the Greeks had for us. They began to mock Judaism and enact laws against it. First they locked up the synagogues and schools. People prayed and studied in one another’s homes.

Then, the Greeks passed a law that all Jews had to write a sentence stating they had no portion in the G‑d of Israel on the horns of their livestock and on their doors. The Jews sold their livestock and removed the doors from their homes.

The Greeks passed a law outlawing circumcision. The Jews made up secret signs through which they announced circumcision ceremonies, and guests risked their lives to go wish the new parents Mazel Tov!”

The Greek soldiers started assaulting Jewish women The Greeks outlawed Shabbat, the celebration of the New Moon, and Torah study. Jews hid in caves and continued to observe all three. The Greeks found hundreds of ways to try to stamp out Judaism. Jews found hundreds of ways to quietly rebel and to remain what they had always been. Then the Greek soldiers started assaulting Jewish women. The governor made a decree—unfortunately, a common one in ancient cultures—called jus primae noctis, “first night rights.” The governor would kidnap and assault every bride on her wedding night.

And then the Jews went to war.

The victory we celebrate on Chanukah is a victory on many levels. It is a victory of the few over the many, of light over darkness, of Jewish continuity in the face of all those who had sought, or would seek to, wipe out Judaism and Jewish history.

The Jewish people—men and women—defied every Greek law with enormous self-sacrifice, yet it was largely by and for the sake of Jewish women that the Maccabees were led to declare war.

The decisive moment occurred when one Jewish woman looked her brothers in the eye and told them, “You cannot let this happen to me.” It was a war, first and foremost, for sanctity—the sanctity of the Temple, the sanctity of Torah, and the sanctity of every human being.

Among the many miracles we acknowledge and commemorate as we kindle the lights of the menorah, we also acknowledge the simple truth of every woman’s sanctity and her right to personal safety and dignity.

It’s a detail well worth remembering.

Chana Kroll is an alumna of Machon Chana Yeshiva for Women in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. Prior to moving to New York, she taught at a boarding school/shelter for runaways and young people whose families were homeless.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Rubertha L. Blackman December 11, 2012

When I first heard about the Macabbee brothers and the revolt I wondered where is the woman. I always read about men but where was the women, for we are always there. I research and found out about Judith. I always look forward to Chanukah as I love to light my soul and heart with this amazingiracle. Reply

Maria New York, NY December 2, 2010

Women's sanctity and dignity "...we also acknowledge the simple truth of every's woman sanctity and her right to personal safety and dignity. It's a detail well worth remembering."
How true, opportune, and appropriate are those words! Especially today, when women needing to travel are forced choose between humiliating body scans or vexing touch of even private areas, under the excuse of "security measures". Will we lamely submit to the Foces of Darkness, or will we reclaim our Maccabee spirit and stand for the Word of ou G-d and our right to live with dignity? Reply

Shlomo New York, New York November 30, 2010

another truth the fight was really between the "greek Jews" who wanted to assimilate and thr tranditionalists headed by the Saducee Cohanim.

Isn't today's conflict similar wheer the tradiionalists are against the assimilationist, intermarried, J street types? Reply

Anonymous NYC November 30, 2010

A greater detail to remember The simple truth to acknowledge is that every human being (female and male) is morally entitled to sanctity and has the same moral right to personal safety and dignity.

A more fitting title would be either motivated Jewish men going to war or How a Jewish woman inspired the Maccabees. Reply

Anonymous Rio de Janeiro, RJ/Brazil November 29, 2010

thanks Although I am not Jewish, the Book of Maccabee has an important meaning for me. For me this book shows how a woman can face the evil and encourage your entire family to do the right thing to do.

Sorry to be talking about something here, I'm not Jewish, I was raised within Christianity. But I'm much more of what we call the Old Testament than that of the New. I follow the articles of you more or less a year. Not out of curiosity, I'm not looking for anything but a better understanding of what Christians call the Old Testament and I think anyone can better explain the books that make up the Old Testament that the guardians of it, the Jews.
I would like to thank you for keeping this site, it has been a blessing in my life. Sorry for English, but I used a translator. Is my English is very poor so I can express myself properly. Reply

Miss Chana Kroll November 5, 2009

Source The source noted in the book where I first saw this midrash is Midrash L'Chanukah, Nusah 3. The book where I found it quoted is a collection of Techinas (prayers written to be said outside the set prayer services found in the prayerbook) translated into English by Rivka Zakutinsky, entitled Techinas: A Voice from the Heart. She quotes the midrash more extensively than I have here, and follows it with one of the Techinas composed for women to say during Chanukah. The decree of prima nostra and the Jewish responses to it, minus the wedding scene, are found elsewhere in the works of rabbis and Jewish scholars from the days just after the war until now. Reply

Hana-Bashe Baltimore, MD, USA December 19, 2007

Sources According to the World Union of Jewish Students website, the sources of this Midrash are as follows: M. Y. Ben Gurion, miMekor Yisrael 1; Y. D. Eisenstein, Otzar Midrashim: Hannukah. This story is a powerful reminder of how *kadosh* we Jewish women truly are. Thank you, Chana!

Sara Los Angeles, CA, USA December 4, 2007

Source? Hi what is the source of this story? It is very touching, but I have never heard of it before? Reply

Related Topics
This page in other languages