Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info
Chabad.org » The Rebbe » Life » Discovering the Rebbe » Do Married Spouses Have Private Lives Too?








Discovering the Rebbe
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment9 Comments

Do Married Spouses Have Private Lives Too?

So, you got married, does your spouse need to know everything you do? Could there possibly be certain private matters that you need not share with your soul mate?

In a previous post, I wrote about the "aggrieved woman." The woman read both Yiddish and Hebrew, and the Rebbe wrote many times to her in both these languages. Which led me to wonder, why did the Rebbe write to her numerous times in English, when the Rebbe was certainly more comfortable with Yiddish?

As I wrote in my post on this subject, this couple was very close to the Rebbe, and both spouses received many letters from the Rebbe.

It seems apparent to me that the Rebbe was concerned that sometimes one of the spouses would inadvertently open a letter he addressed to the other. Most of the time, it wouldn't make a difference; at times, however, the contents were intended for the addressee only.

Perhaps those letters written in English were the ones that the Rebbe felt were for the eyes of the wife only; not for the husband, who was an immigrant and did not read English.

In JEM's newest film – Sensitivity: The Rebbe's compassionate attention to "the little things" – there is an anecdote related by Rabbi Shimon Lazaroff, director of Chabad-Lubavitch in Texas, that relays a similar message.

Here is the transcript provided by JEM:

One time, while in a private audience after I got married, I asked the Rebbe a few questions.

The Rebbe answered all of them, aside for one. I realized this after I came out of the Rebbe's room, when I was transcribing the Rebbe's answers—there was this one question that the Rebbe didn't answer. I wondered: Did I not hear? Did I forget what he said?

Sure enough, in the evening the Rebbe's secretary, Rabbi Hodakov, calls me, "In your audience with the Rebbe, you asked a question…" And he relayed to me the Rebbe's answer to the question.

It was a private matter, and my wife was with me in the audience. The Rebbe didn't want to answer in front of my wife.

In other words, the way I saw it, the Rebbe was so sensitive and careful about the most little thing. That answer was not appropriate to be said in front of my wife…"

So, my take is that being married doesn't completely preclude some privacy.

What do you think?


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Nov 30, 2009
Appropriate
Regarding 'an effort... as much as possible is shared with the partner'; some things need not be said. Why mention it unless it has a positive impact on the development and peace within the relationship? For example, a person speaking ill of self, however trivial, to a spouse. To uphold the dignity and sanctity of a marriage, it is beneficial to keep such talk for a friend, parent, mashpia/mentor, unless it directly concerns spouse. A spouse may be a 'best friend' without negative or idle chatter.
Posted By Anonymous, Sydney, Australia

Posted: Nov 25, 2009
secrets
i think if the information is painful or harmful it should not be said on the other hand dont say it is none of your buisness
Posted By efraim, london, uk

Posted: Oct 12, 2009
Appropriate Secrets
I think that the question is what is in the best interests of the spouse. Withholding information from one's spouse should only be done when that information might be painful or harmful for them. If, for example, a wife's respect for her husband might be diminished if she was privy to a certain personal issue of his, that might be cause for concealing it, or revealing it with caution.
The Rebbe may not have been showing any example regarding what spouses tell each other. It is possible that the Rebbe protected the privacy of people, and left it up to them to be the ones who would clue their spouses in.
Posted By Anonymous, Davis

Posted: Aug 23, 2009
privacy
If the Rebbe felt it was necessary at times to maintain privacy, then obviously it is necessary at times. However, we must make sure that we make as conscious of an effort as possible that as much as possible is shared with the partner. For if two are to unite as one, they must live and breath and feel as one. That can not be done when there is excessive privacy.
Posted By Shmulik, Chicago, IL

Posted: Aug 21, 2009
Private livesI
I think the Rebbe was showing consideration that each of us has a responsibility to evaluate the impact of our "secrets" on others, particularly our spouses. If the Rebbe says something that might be sensitive to one of the spouses, he is taking that responsibility onto himself and denying it to the individual. More of us should show the restraint and thoughtfulness the Rebbi exhibited.
Posted By Mathiya, Denver, CO

Posted: Aug 21, 2009
Private Lives
There can be no real, general justification for a private life. It cannot be a blanket YES or NO. It must be based on the specific situation, the reasons and the intention. It cannot be for deception or be self-serving.
Posted By Bonnie/Basha Reiss, Naperville, Il

Posted: Aug 20, 2009
one life
When you marry, you go from being two people leading two lives to a pair leading a life together. There is no such thing as "his life" and "her life". They are together. What he does affects her and what she does affects him.

I agree with Alex. There are things that may need to be reflected on privately for a bit, but shared ASAP.

And it is never okay to say "It is none of your business."

I receive that one regularly. Not fun. Leads to hurt feelings, mistrust, etc.
Posted By Anonymous, city

Posted: Aug 17, 2009
I agree with alex
I think that you are generalizing...
Posted By gershon

Posted: Aug 17, 2009
Do Married Spouses Have Private Lives Too?
Please consider the answer may lead to confusion with this title.

The Rebbe action example show a good example by it self, but attaching to "Married Spouses Have Private Lives" is a different story.

Consider the posibility that some times an advice may be given to a spouse on how to conduct him selve to solve family issues, and may be at that time the matter is highly sensitive for the other spouse to hear. A temporary privacy on a topic [not to develop a private live] may help "Shalom Bais" as long as it will be disclosed when it is a proper time.

That does not means that the issue solved should be keeped private, nor secret. On the contrary, spouses should have share it ASAP when it is apropiate for both.

But having private lives may lead to unwanted scenarios and should be avoided...
Posted By Alex


 



By Dovid Zaklikowski   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Dovid Zaklikowski is the director of Lubavitch Archives and is on the editorial staff of Chabad.org. Dovid and his wife Chana Raizel are the proud parents of four: Motti, Meir, Shaina & Moshe Binyomin.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.