Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Parenting
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » Parenting » Parenting & Education » Help! I've got kids... » Should Parents Apologize to their Children?








Help! I've got kids...
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment10 Comments

Should Parents Apologize to their Children?

We are all wrong. At least, we are all wrong some of the time. Still, we're all right. That's because we're all right a lot of the time as well. No one is all wrong all of the time, nor is anyone always right.

Confused? I'll say it more simply: every single one of us makes mistakes sometimes. Every single one of us is imperfect. Every single one of us needs to improve in some way.

You'd think this was obvious, but it is not. There are many parents who present themselves to their kids as if perfect. Such parents never apologize for anything because, in their opinion, they are never wrong. At the same time, they may be very hard on their children – quick to identify mistakes and deficiencies and intent on hearing apologies for wrongdoings. When children are young, they have no choice but to absorb the criticism and complaints. But when they become adolescents, they may take to talking back and challenging the parent.

"You're always screaming at me!" a teen might complain. "That's because you never listen!" retorts the parent. The parent actually teaches the child, through his or her model, that defensive remarks are appropriate ways to respond to criticism. Unfortunately, such a lesson will handicap the child later on in his or her adult relationships. Defensiveness doesn't work! It pushes people apart instead of bringing them closer together. Moreover, it indicates a haughty attitude, the kind of attitude that is loathed by G‑d. The Talmud is replete with condemnations of haughtiness and similarly replete with praise for those who are humble. This Talmudic statement sums it up powerfully: "Someone haughty in spirit, it is as though he were an idolater" (Sotah 4b). He worships himself! Humility allows people to apologize. Arrogance holds them back. What works is acknowledgement. Hearing, accepting and validating a complaint really works in marriage, parenting and professional situations. But children need to experience this process first hand. They need to learn it from their parents.

So what should a parent say when accused of screaming too much? The parent might respond: "You're right, I do scream a lot. I'm sorry. I shouldn't be doing that. I need to handle my frustration better." This attention, acknowledgement and validation amounts to a very nice apology. It will help the child learn to formulate similar responses to attacks. In addition, it will help the child acknowledge his or her own role in the current dispute. An older child is much more likely to say something like, "I know you're frustrated – I didn't do what I said I would. It's not your fault. I'm really sorry. I'll get to it today." A younger one might say, "That's okay, Mommy. I'm sorry, too." When the parent leads the way by apologizing, children find it easier and more natural to follow suit.

A good apology is much more than "I'm sorry." Unless the person states what he or she is sorry about, the words can feel empty and cold. This is where the acknowledgment part comes in: acknowledgment is a summary of the wrongdoing as it affects the other person. When arriving late, for example, a person would say something like, "I'm sorry I'm late. I've kept you waiting." This short, simple-but-complete message names the mistake and its ramifications. Here are a few more examples:

  • "I'm sorry I called you 'immature.' I know that hurt your feelings."
  • "I'm sorry I forgot to buy you the cookies I promised to pick up. I know you must be very disappointed."
  • "I'm sorry I bumped into you. Are you alright?"

Simple and sincere apologies are powerful. They heal relationship wounds. Showing kids how it is done gives them a skill that will truly enhance their lives.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Nov 24, 2010
One of the first lessons taught in any therapy is that you can't change another person; the only person you can change is yourself. It’s very perceptive of you to wish that your mother would learn some “common courtesy and humility.” These qualities really do smooth out the bumps in relationships. So - how about trying it yourself?

“Common courtesy.” It takes two to fight. When one party stays polite and even-tempered, refuses to scream or to retaliate– then it’s difficult to carry on a fight. I suggest you choose one area of “fighting” and focus on changing your behavior. For instance, you might resolve that you will not raise your voice. It’s not easy – but it’s amazing how keeping your voice calm will change the dynamics of any disagreement. Or, you might decide to work on not “answering back” with accusations of your own (“Well, yesterday YOU embarrassed me in front of my best friend!”).

Occasionally you might stop the whole argument in its tracks and completely flummox your mom by saying “You’re right, I’m sorry if I hurt you, I’ll try not to do it again.”

“Humility.” Your mother is still your mother; she’s got some more years and life experience under her belt than you do. Remembering that a little more often, and being open to the possibility that you might actually (gasp!) be wrong, will probably do you a world of good

Two great fringe benefits of trying to adopt some of this courtesy and humility yourself:

1. This kind of behavior tends to be contagious. Start modeling these qualities, and I wouldn’t be at all surprised if you end up with a gentler kinder mom as well.
2. These qualities work in every sort of relationship – not only with your mother, but with friends, teachers, siblings, etc. Cultivate them, and life will roll along so much more smoothly…
Posted By Chaya Sara Silberberg for chabad.org, West Bloomfield, MI

Posted: Nov 16, 2010
proud, condecending mother
I am constantly fighting with my mum, and she NEVER apologizes, even when I'm right most of the time. But because dad doesn't want her to leave (because she took off for a week once), he forces me to take the fall and humble myself and apologize. I'm so over it!

But even when I do, she still doesn't apologize, and so it's just this underlying fury in me because I feel unjustified and wrongly done by, and nothing is ever fully resolved.

I wish she could learn some common courtesy and humility! It seriously tees me off.

Do you have any tips of ways I can deal with her immaturity?
Posted By ukulele32, Melbourne, Australia

Posted: Nov 30, 2009
Question: what do we do when we're on the other end of this argument? My parents are constantly finding faults in me and have never apologized for their mistakes. How should I act to improve the situation? Should I just remain quiet and let the storm pass or should I say something back?

Thanks
Posted By Anonymous, Denver

Posted: Oct 30, 2009
what about the other side of the coin
B"H
Perhaps you could do a piece on Should Children Apologize to their Parents. In this day and age when children are not taught proper Jewish values like 'kibud av veaim' (honoring parents) with all its ramifications and there is the fear of social justice which may take the side of the child over the parent - parents sometimes feel the need to apologize for something the KID DID THAT WAS WRONG.
Posted By Blumah
via kansasjewish.com

Posted: Oct 29, 2009
yes...
Yes this works....Sorry is as sorry does...a parent should follow through with good resolutions for the future...but I think a lot of the pain can be removed from a stinging "parenting mistake" if the parents shows the child that they regret it.

and contrary to what some believe, it strengthens the child's respect for the parent rather than the opposite..
Posted By mimi, Yirushalaim

Posted: Oct 28, 2009
should parents apologize
I should apologize for my bad joke in answer to this question earlier. Inb truth, it is very vauable to apologize to our kids for all the reasons above. Also, I think it's when we see our own worst qualities in our kids that we tend to lash out. Apologizing to them may help us forgive our own mistakes as well.
Posted By Chuck, LA, CA

Posted: Oct 28, 2009
Should parents apoligise?
Yes, when we are wrong. So many times we makes mistakes, short tempered, angry because things are not going are way. And who do we lash at? The ones that we love! I have learned not to make the same mistakes as my parents when it came to parenting. We were not allowed to speak unless spoken too, whipped for any and all reasons. My belief is to discipline a child and train a child so that they will not end up in jail! But when I am wrong, I do apologize. When my children are wrong in their behavior and actions, they have to apologize too! It makes you more human! And by this, we are closer in our relationship!
Posted By Debra, Atlanta, GA

Posted: Oct 27, 2009
Marcy
We may not be in the same boat, but we are surely in the same small pond.

But my child is older, and I can tell you that yes it works!

Even better, when they see small mistakes apologized for and then quickly forgotten they learn this too, and they learn to not make mountains out of molehills.
Posted By Sarah, W Bloomfield, MI/USA

Posted: Oct 27, 2009
You think I scream too much?
How about this as a response...

You think I scream too much?

YOU THINK I SCREAM TOO MUCH?????

I HAVE NOT SCREAMED TOO MUCH!!!!!

OK, NOW, I'M SCREAMING TOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!! YOU HEAR THE DIFFERENCE??????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted By chuck, los angeles, ca

Posted: Oct 26, 2009
Thank you
This is so right! I was brought up to think that my parents were never wrong and I felt frustrated when I would see that they weren't correct. It taught me that I should be perfect and when I wasn't I would beat up on myself.
Today I apologize to my kids so they can learn that it's o.k. to make mistakes and own the responsibility. They are still young, so I'm not sure if the experiment will work, but I sure hope they turn out better adjusted than me.
Posted By Marcy, Dallas, Texas


 



By Sara Chana Radcliffe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Sarah Chana Radcliffe, M.Ed.,C.Psych.Assoc. is the author of "Raise Your Kids without Raising Your Voice" and The Delicate Balance published by Targum Press. Click here to visit her website.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.