HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Blogs » Save this Marriage » No Criticism Please!








Save this Marriage
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

No Criticism Please!

Criticism hurts. It hurts so much it can destroy any relationship it touches. Critical parents push their kids away. Critical mothers- or fathers-in-law alienate their children's spouses. Critical bosses cause employees to quit their jobs. It should be no surprise then that criticism can also wreak havoc on a marriage.

Criticism does not have to be verbal. It is, after all, an attitude of rejection and that attitude can be conveyed in many ways: a frown, an unhappy vibe, a sigh, or even silence -- all can convey rebuke, disappointment or displeasure. The critical attitude communicates a lack of acceptance. It's the complete opposite of praise, celebration, appreciation, pleasure or pride. When people experience the rejection of criticism they suffer intense emotional pain. They desperately want to avoid the source of that pain – the critical person in their lives.

Despite the cost of criticism, most spouses use this communication tool liberally. When upset, irritated or frustrated with their partner, they say so -- with words or otherwise. They think it's their "right" to honestly show their feelings. They don't seem to notice or care that exercising this right can only cause them harm. Indulging in negativity squelches love. Yes, the place is a mess; yes, I did forget to pay the bill; yes, my manners could use some improvement – but if you constantly point out my flaws I won't like you very much. And yet, in the moment, people ignore this reality, reaching instead for the instant emotional gratification of being right.

Avoiding, Reducing & Eliminating Criticism

Criticism can literally destroy a marriage – it is a very dangerous tool. Like anger, it "undoes" love and harms its victims. As it states in Proverbs: "a soothing tongue is a tree of life, but harsh words break the spirit." Hurting one's partner hurts one's marriage. Therefore, a person who wants to be happily married should resolve to keep critical communications down to the barest minimum. Even if one's spouse is seriously flawed, criticism has to be avoided.

Follow the 95-5 Rule: 95% of communications should be pleasant, positive, warm, up-beat and otherwise good-feeling. Another 5% can be slightly less than good-feeling, including: instructions, grumpy moods and, among other things, criticism. This doesn't leave much space for criticism, as you can see.

If you want to correct a spouse's behavior, use positive reinforcement for the opposite behavior (i.e. get very excited about a cleaned dish rather than critical about an unclean one). Use humor (not sarcasm) to make some points. When you decide you want to use part of your tiny criticism allotment, then do so very carefully in order to minimize the damage. Stay away from insults, character assignation, harsh language, speaking in a loud voice and so on. Use the sandwich approach instead: positive, critical part, positive again.

If there are bigger issues to resolve, seek marriage counseling. Instead of criticizing and complaining. Let a professional gently guide your spouse to more appropriate behavior.

Removing criticism from your marriage can only help. Even if your spouse is the critical one, your own efforts can raise the marriage to a higher level. Never sink down to the bad behavior of your partner in order to try to make things better – the failure rate of that strategy is 100%. Be the best spouse you can be and ask G‑d to bless your efforts with success. You can even ask Him to help your spouse improve his or her problematic behaviors – since you can always pray for anything at all and G‑d has the power to solve every problem. Your positive efforts are sure to bring positive results in the easiest, most pleasant way possible.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: May 1, 2011
What do I do?
What do I do when I tell my my wife nicely at least 3 or 4 or 5 times:
1. Put caps on soap dispensers, toothpaste, bottles, etc. Leaving them off is annoying, wastes the product, causes ME to go out and buy more product which is again ruined and so on...
2. Keep her own closet and bathroom clean
3. Learn to cook or bake -- anything! I make almost every dinner (except when it is a frozen dinner which she burns -- no joke.)
4. Learn how to address envelopes
5. Learn how to read Hebrew (or at least start)
6. Write thank you notes when people give gifts -- not 2 months (or more) later after I beg her to do so.
7. Help with some of the chores around the house. I take care of ALL of the maintenance issues, phone calls, repair people, etc.
8. Clean up dishes after dinner (the one I always cook or the one she burns). I have asked her to take cooking lessons (toegether with me).
9. Leaving food out.
By the way, we BOTH split the baby duties evenly and I am stuck doing 100% of everything else.
Posted By Moishe Kapoyer, Chicago, IL

Posted: Sep 8, 2009
Tired of being put down, Baltimore, MD
Hi, that sounds really sad & l can relate. My husband & l have been going through a few rough patches lately. One of the real intimacy killers for me is his constant criticism. Its like he thinks it's his right to criticize me any time. l am usually the half cup full but this criticism is wearing me out. Why does he criticize? My threshold and putting up with it is decreasing. It took alot to get me down b4 but now even a small criticism is harder to jump back up from. l also generally do not cope the best with criticism so it has taken me some time to take it objectively and then dish it back to him but only ends up in out of control arguments. l have been sworn at, called terrible names, belittled, criticized in front of others/children, pushed around when l think l am standing up for myself, etc It is hard to go through because my husband is someone l usually really admire and look up to. He just can't seem to help himself. Then l try to criticize back leads to no intimacy. Answer?
Posted By Anonymous, Melbourne, Australia

Posted: Aug 6, 2009
Lets hope I can carry it out
I totally agree. It does take quite a bit of work though.
Anyway I tried it today when I decided to stop being angry about being wronged but to tell the other what they did wrong and why I feel wronged.
After your article I'm just letting it go. It's taking some work but I know it's the right thing.
Thank You
Posted By Anonymous, Cedarhurst, NY

Posted: Aug 5, 2009
criticism
To: Tired of being put down, Baltimore, MD

A woman complaining is like a baby crying; it's never about what she says its about. Advice: don't respond directly to her complaints. Just stand up, put your arms around her, hold her, tell her you love her, list many things you and the family are happy about. Figure out what you can do to help her. Don't defend.

Also, interpret for your baby what Mommy has just said...

"It sounds like Mommy is upset about something. Let's see what we can do to make Mommy happy." Then do the first part of this email. Next, ask the baby what we can do to make mommy happy. The baby may know best.

Good luck. Love can be hard, but worth the effort.

Posted By cw, calabasas, ca

Posted: Aug 5, 2009
Criticism
What do you do when your wife is critical of everything you and you children do? She always points out the negative in any situation, uses profanity towards both you and the children and no matter how many times you ask her to stop she just blows you off and won't. Just last night I was Skyping with my 3 year old daughter when my wife came in to ask her if she wanted watermelon or canalop with dinner. I told the babby to say please and my wife asked my why the %^$ she had to say please when she was asking a question. She mubled something else a walked out of the room. I finished speaking with my daughter and told her to go eat dinner? I have tried everything I can think of and am at my wits end. With Hashem's help I will find a way to make the marrraige happy. Or are my kids and I destine to be criticised for ever?
Posted By Tired of being put down, Baltimore, MD

Posted: July 14, 2009
Criticism
Even critics should not be hated but rather understood. Thus the poem:

I hate the guys
Who criticise
The other guys
Whose enterprise
Has made them rise
Above the guys
Who criticise.

Is basically flawed.
Posted By David Chester, Petach Tikva, Israel

Posted: July 13, 2009
criticism
A radio psychologist offered this advice recently: whenever you think you need a marriage therapist, instead of going, just think, "What can I do today to help my spouse." The effort will yield better results than a therapist. Sounds right to me, don't you think?
Posted By Anonymous, calabasas, CA


 



By Sara Chana Radcliffe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Sarah Chana Radcliffe, M.Ed.,C.Psych.Assoc. is the author of "Raise Your Kids without Raising Your Voice" and The Delicate Balance published by Targum Press. Click here to visit her website.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.