HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Should Netanyahu Proclaim Israel as our G‑d-Given Land?








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment6 Comments

Should Netanyahu Proclaim that Israel is our G‑d-Given Land?

Ask the Rabbi sessions are always unpredictable. Any topic is fair game, and being thrown a curveball is not uncommon. Therefore last week when I participated in an Ask the Rabbi forum, I should not have been surprised by the first question: "Should Benjamin 'Bibi' Netanyahu announce that Israel is our G‑d-given land?"

Bibi's major policy address yesterday has left a lot of people unhappy. Did Bibi blink in the face of American pressure by accepting a (sort of) Palestinian State? Has he sent the ball soaring back into the world's court by insisting that Israel must be accepted as a secure Jewish homeland and that our claim predates the Holocaust, the British Mandate, Ottoman Empire and Roman conquest?

But I think that the question posed to me this past week is perhaps the most germane of all.

In this week's Torah portion (Numbers 13-15) we read about the Jewish nation's first attempt to enter their homeland. Here's the background: Ten spies returned from their reconnaissance mission in Canaan with a slanderous report, causing the demoralized Jews to doubt their ability to conquer the Land. Due to their lack of faith, G‑d decreed that that generation would indeed not enter the Promised Land. Realizing their mistake, a group of Jews made an about-face; they armed themselves and prepared to enter the land by force.

Moses warned this group not to go, "It will not succeed! Do not go up," he entreated, "for G‑d is not among you!"

But the group would not be dissuaded. A battle ensued and the would-be conquerors were mercilessly beaten back by the Canaanites.

From the contentious reference to the "Rock of Israel" in Israel's Declaration of Independence to Bibi's latest policy address, G‑d has been conspicuously missing in Israeli public discourse. Whilst happy to attribute minimal losses from constant attritional rocket attacks to "miracles," giving G‑d proper credit seems to be unthinkable.

As a Jewish nation in a Jewish land, G‑d and His values, as espoused in the Torah – and clearly expressed in the Talmud and the Code of Jewish Law – must be part of our national discourse. G‑d has much to say about who are the rightful owners of the Land and about how to defend Jewish life and live in peace.

After three thousand years, Moses' message must still resonate for us. Whether in our business dealings, personal relationships or the Arab-Israeli conflict, if G‑d is not with us, ultimately "it will not succeed." For this reason, since time immemorial the term b'ezrat Hashem, "G‑d willing," has been part of our vocabulary. A true peace must include G‑d in the agreement.

May it be speedily in our time. G‑d willing.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: June 23, 2009
The land of Israel
How much of the Land of Cana'an (wherever that is) is actually for the Jews? Our history is filled with periods of time where this occupation is variable. During Bibilical times in particular, it seems that we always had to share in some form or another our Land with foreigners. We cannot now claim a state with set boarders where no foreigner is permitted to live permanently, nor should we be limited in the region around which our present-day Israel is founded as to where our settlements can be located.

However it is more about politics than land occupancy which Nataniahu is concerned and he seems to have got caught up in the same web as most of our would-be politicians. There are ideal forms of government where the land is shared so well that the position of the boarders is not relevant, if all can live and work on this land and if the advantage of this is paid as a tax instead of the earnings from the land, then it is not important where the politics ends and the religion begins.
Posted By David Chester, Petach Tikva, Israel

Posted: June 22, 2009
Bibi Didn't Speak The Truth. That's How You Know.
How do you know an Israeli leader is going to be good for the Jewish people, these days?

Because he or she will stand up, tell the world the truth about the fabrication of the so-called "Palestinian" people (who don't exist).

Did Bibi do that? No. In fact he is perpetuating the lie by calling them Palestinians and by considering that they are a people he would give land to.

A true leader of the Jews would stand up, tell the world the lie about the "Palestinians", take back the Temple Mount from the Arab Waqf, remove every last Arab from residence in the land, and put a swift end to any and all attacks on Jews in Israel rather than sit there and allow shelling for a decade.

Until that happens, Israeli leaders, the West, and the Arabs are ALL doing nothing more than taking Israel apart, piece by piece. It's been a process of many years now, this dismantling of Israel, and it's so far along now that unless Israel gets a true leader soon, it will all be over.
Posted By SarahRachel, Norfolk, VA

Posted: June 22, 2009
be'ezrat Hashem
The question of "G-d willing" is more difficult that it may seem. There is a group of observant Jews who do not accept Zionism as valid and see the modern state of Israel as based, not on Judaism, but on secular nationalism.

The right to life, the right to exist, is considered an inalienable right in American political philosophy. Thus America, and then the United Nations, recognized the right of Jews to exist in the land of Israel. Zionism was based on this modern notion as well.

The problem for secular nationalism, however, is the Torah. According to the Torah, we Jews must live a certain way to hold onto the Promised Land. If we do not, the land, itself, will vomit us out.

Netanyahu cannot lay claim to the land for us on any other basis. But the choice is ours, both life and death, to follow the Torah or not. Secular nationalism is not enough to secure the Holy Land for us.
Posted By shlomo, Reno, Nevada

Posted: June 19, 2009
examples
If the "jews" are an example, where is their temple to the "GOD"? and why is this subject matter being brought up now and not when the UN charter was "agreed" in 1948? Sound a lot like the example in the bible. More excuses and lack of faith.
Posted By chris rubio, Hormigueros, Puerto Rico

Posted: June 18, 2009
G-d wants Israel to Obey
Faith in G-d makes him glad. He has promised for thousands of years that Israel are his people and entitled to the Land he gave Abraham.

The Moses story is one of lack of faith (doubt) ...not timing. G-d will protect his people, isn't that evident in the past victories?

G-d only and always asks for Israel and Judah to obey: Hosea 12:6 Therefore, return to your God,
Observe kindness and justice,
And wait for your God continually.

We pray that Israel and Judah's eyes are open and ears are hearing, Amen.
Posted By Anonymous, Phila, USA

Posted: June 17, 2009
the announcement

This is a wonderful article.

Please explain how announcing Israel is our g-d given land makes it that g-d is among us.

How do we know we are not like the group of spies that after hearing the decree chose to go back and fight even after hearing from Moses that g-d would not be amongst them?

Thank you,
J
Posted By Anonymous, San Francsico, Ca


 



By Eli Pink   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Eli Pink lives in Leeds, England, where he juggles his role as Director of Education for Lubavitch Foundation of Leeds with his familial responsibilities. His Torah E-Thoughts are read by hundreds of people and he teaches a range of Torah classes each week.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.