HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Blogs » Let's Go For Coffee » Does G-d Have ADD?








Let's Go For Coffee
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment11 Comments

Does G-d Have ADD?

Hold on my dear editors, before you get all up in arms in self-righteous indignation at my insolence, before you toss this article into your overflowing trash bin, and me with it out the office door, hear me out. G‑d knows more than anyone how much I need His help in my life. I certainly would not want to alienate or anger Him by being disrespectful!

Lately, when a close friend confided that she was diagnosed with ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder), I decided to learn a little bit more about this condition.

My research led me to understand that individuals with ADD or ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder) as it is now officially called, have problems coping with distractibility, procrastination and prioritization. They also have frequent mood swings, ranging from extreme attentiveness to cold negligence (could that explain why my friend sometimes doesn't call for weeks on end, and other times, several times a day?).

While many refer to ADD as a disorder, nowadays many experts on this topic are seeing it more as a "mode." As one explained, people with ADD often have tremendous advantages, such as "super-charged" creative brains, original out-of-the-box thinking and a perception of details that few of the rest of us would notice (like the tiny patch on my dining room ceiling where the paint is beginning to peel that my friend made sure to point out to me).

The problem, however, lies with their brains' filters--their inability to filter out unimportant or unnecessary details and distractions. Typically, someone with ADD will have so much information accosting him at every moment of his day that he is unable to prioritize, and often essential tasks get sidelined for other less important ones. With so much happening in their brains and the constant deluge of information, they also often find it difficult to pick up on normal social cues--unless they consciously focus on the needs of those around them (maybe that would explain her loudly pointing out the peeling paint just when I was trying to impress a room full of important guests…)

With their extremely detailed brains, people with ADD are often plagued by an unattainable pursuit of perfection, which in turn, prevents them from completing almost-finished tasks, in a vicious cycle of running off to the next thing and then the next… (hmmm, I guess that explains her many job changes…).

Which all leads me back to G‑d.

The Talmud declares that "the kingdom of Heaven is similar to the kingdom of earth"--that the structures of human society and the patterns of human behavior reflect the manner in which the Creator relates to and runs His world.

Everything in our physical world has a spiritual source.

So much so that one of the Chassidic Rebbes was able to identify a physical membrane in the brain, one that was medically unknown at the time, from his understanding of the spiritual realms. He understood that if this existed on the spiritual plane, it must have a counterpart in the physical body of man.

As well, once when an individual who had committed a very severe sin came for a private audience with Rabbi Dovber of Lubavitch, "the Mitteler Rebbe," the Rebbe secluded himself for several hours in deep contemplation and somber introspection before responding. He explained that in order to help this individual he, too, had to find, on some level, some subtle, slight trace of that sin in his own character. It took him several hours of soul-searching until he could finally discover some resemblance of the source of that condition, in order to provide the individual with an appropriate path of return.

This story gives me comfort—even great and perfect people can relate to us smaller individuals because on some subtle level, they too experience some degree of the challenges or deficiencies that we have.

And so, I postulate, if the condition of ADD exists in our world, can it not mean that G‑d, the perfect being, at times chooses, for whatever reason, to enter into this mode of behavior in dealing with us?

And that's what brings me to possible subtle traces of distractibility, procrastination and pursuit of perfection in how G‑d chooses to run our world.

Personally, I am unable to fathom all the detailed tasks that G‑d must have on His post-it "To Do" list on His heavenly desk. But one thing that I do know has been His priority, from the beginning of time: to bring our world to a state of perfection and completion, its final redemption. That has been His stated purpose from time immemorial.

Throughout our long history, there have been many times when we felt like…AHHHH, it's finally going to happen. How many times did our nation become enthusiastically hopeful, trusting that G‑d is finally hearing our cries and "tuning in" to our suffering, to once and for all end it?

There were signs that the redemption was coming; there were predictions from great and righteous people of it happening imminently. And the dates came and passed…

We're still here in our bitter exile. And the only explanation that I can come up with is that G‑d is waiting for our world to reach its ultimate perfection. Just when the redemption is about to happen, He gets involved in all the other (minor, in comparison) projects and accomplishments that He wants completed.

So what's the solution?

From what I read, the key for someone with ADD (other than medication, therapy and possible changes of diet), is to come to an understanding of how his brain works, his strengths and his weaknesses and how his behavior is hurting not only himself, but also those that he truly loves. Once he is keenly aware of this, and attuned to the needs and feelings of those around him, he can learn that occasionally he must submit his own perspective and trust those around him.

So, perhaps it is time for us to honestly open up to G‑d. To really express to Him just how keenly we need this finale of His own grand plan. To show Him just how much this waiting is causing us to suffer.

And to ask Him to give up His desire for detailed perfection, and finally just make it happen!


11 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: July 16, 2009
To Steven
The best definitions of ADD are given in Driven to Distraction, by Hallowell and Ratey, and The ADD Brain, by Monroe Gross.
Posted By Edward Gershon Cherlin, Cupertino, CA

Posted: July 15, 2009
I'm fascinated by ADD and ADHD
It's unfortunate that these "disorders" are stigmatized considering the amazing parts of having ADD such as the unique creativity and thinking out of the box! I know some adults who still take medication, and they are great fathers and have functional lives and jobs. Thankfully, their "wildness" is appreciated and celebrated, and therefore they are a pleasure to be with; they feel they have nothing to be ashamed of.
Posted By m

Posted: June 7, 2009
To Chana
Can you post where this definition of ADD is found and elaborated upon? I am fascinated.
Posted By Steven

Posted: June 6, 2009
To all with ADD/ADHD
I too was diagnosed with ADHD when I was a young boy. And yes, I had my ups and downs. But now as I see Hashem's purpose for me unfold in my life, I recognize that ADHD has become a critical asset and I praise Hashem for the wonderful gift He has given me! If you look close enough, I beleive you too will see the blessing as I did!
Posted By A Gentile, Wasilla , Alaska

Posted: June 3, 2009
Sue
I wish I could do the remo myself. But when I say he is doing it, I mean the actual work, and I don't have those skills!

And yes, the nearly 24 hour work time leaves me breathless, and tired!

I think he would have been given the label if he were a generation or two younger than he is (We are both over 50) But in the '50's and '60's we just considered these kids as badly behaved, and no teacher ever worked with them. They just tried to make sure they didn't disrupt class. The brilliant ones (like my husband) got through it by doing enough without working, while actually working to their max. The rest were passed up to the next grade so the teacher wouldn't have to deal with them again. Making them repeat wouldn't have done any good, and coping skills were thirty years into the future.

Long before I thought of ADD I knew he was different, and that there were two sides to this coin. Overall, it has been worth it, but I won't say it is always easy.
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI/USA

Posted: June 3, 2009
To Sarah
Hi, I live with a quite brilliant man, whose massive energy keeps him going nearly 24/7. He also has ADD.
While I cannot see calling having ADD "the mode" of the day, this type of autism is controllable, and possibly, a real blessing to some people.
Any "disability" that the great One has given to you is a gift; a lesson, a pathway to knowledge, a valuable persona.
My husband leaves some detail of every reno, so I suggest to us both that we do the finishing!
Posted By sue, Kanata, ON

Posted: June 2, 2009
Thank you for writing this piece. As someone with ADHD, your understanding and acceptance of this condition means more than I can say.
The years of depression and struggles I've endured has made it difficult to understand ADHD as a gift from G-d. But now with
G-d's love and patience, I have embraced his gift and feel so blessed to have it.
Posted By Anonymous, Toronto, ON, Canada

Posted: June 2, 2009
Learning to Channel ADD as the Strength it Can Be
I believe that it is part of our avodah, and perhaps the Creator's Intent, for those who have ADD to learn how to transform it into the tool and the strength that it truly can be -- and for those of us who are professionals in this field to teach them how to do it. This was part of the brocha I received from the Rebbe when I started an organization devoted to this purpose nearly 20 years ago, and since then, a generation has grown up to prove the wisdom of that blessing. ADD is certainly a two-sided issue -- as are many other things in life. If properly addressed, it becomes a strength. But if not, the research is equally clear. G-d created professionals for a reason.
Posted By Hana Levi Julian, Arad, Israel
via chabadoncampus.org

Posted: June 1, 2009
My husband fits this perfectly. He owns his own company, I couldn't imagine him fitting into any other corporate culture. But within his industry he is known as a brilliant engineer, with over 35 patents. Patents don't go to uncreative people, who don't insist on perfedtion.

Super creative, yes. But can't/won't finish remodeling a home because he won't make some decisions, as things must be the best, good enough just won't do.

We are supposed to emulate HaShem, but this is not what I expected when he said he would try! I didn't even think this was emulating HaShem! HaShem knew I needed to develop this super dose of patience, and I feel I have. So, HaShem answer our prayers, and make the condition of my North American home unimportant.....
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI/USA

Posted: June 1, 2009
ADD Mind, ADD Soul
ADD is defined by our society as a disorder, but it is known to be associated with creativity, compassion, a special kind of hyperfocus (but not on what other people tell us is important), and an inability to sit still for pernicious nonsense. Almost the definition of a Prophet.

I have this condition, and the worst thing I can imagine is somebody offering to make me "normal". With all of the difficulties that I face because of this condition, I would never give it up and lose its benefits.

In some cultures, ADD is taken as a sign of an "old soul". Not that any of us is really older, or has had more lives, but that people with ADD have made more of the lives they had. They cannot pay attention to the things of this world as society demands because their minds and souls are fixed on something better.

I don't know whether that is what happens, only that some people say so. I also know that children with ADD can be led astray, and that society then throws many of them away.
Posted By Edward Gershon Cherlin, Cupertino, CA


 



By Chana Weisberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Chana Weisberg is a writer, editor and lecturer. She authored several books, including her latest, Tending the Garden: The Unique Gifts of the Jewish Woman. She has served as the dean of several women’s educational institutes, and lectures internationally on issues relating to women, faith, relationships and the Jewish soul.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by our content partner, Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.