Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Blogs » Save this Marriage » Wants to Be Religious and Wife Doesn't








Save this Marriage
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

Wants to Be Religious and Wife Doesn't

Dear Bronya,

I have become more ritually observant and unfortunately my wife is not. I understand, and she has stated, that this is not what she "signed up for." My question is how to get past my daily frustration regarding this, especially when it comes to our being role models for our three daughters. I work very long hours and she spends the most time with them.

Frustrated

Dear Frustrated,

I understand the challenges you face, and can certainly understand your frustration. You must keep foremost in mind that above all your marriage must be respected. When a Jewish man and woman marry, they establish, the two of them, a home in Israel. A binyan adei ad—an eternal edifice. Your marriage is for all eternity.

You say that you've become more "ritually observant"; no doubt you're referring to Shabbat and kosher, to tefillin and mezuzah, and I admire you for that. No doubt you are saying the morning prayers, and no doubt you've recognized that the morning blessings end with the passage, "....these are the precepts, the fruit of which man enjoys in this world, while the pricipal reward remains in the World to Come. . . bringing peace. . . between husband and wife..." Furthermore, before even beginning the morning prayers you regularly say the following: "I hereby take upon myself to fulfill the mitzvah, 'Love your fellowman as yourself.'" This mitzvah of ahavat Yisrae' – contrary to some misconception – most definitely applies to one's spouse!

Both of these passages are in the morning prayers. You cannot begin your day without saying them. Think about this, think about the significance. As important as are 'ritual' observances, these sentiments are repeated every single morning—it is with these specific sentiments that you continue in prayer.

So you are frustrated that your partner in life, your soulmate, does not share your passion for ritual observance. What about your passion for making her happy? What about your passion, now that you are more keenly aware of Torah obligations, for loving her unconditionally? Your passion for increasing, in every possible way, the peace between a husband and wife?

Show her what it means to be a servant of Torah. Show her it makes a man more sensitive to his wife, more attuned to her needs and her anxieties and her dreams and her hopes. Make for her a husband who, through his Torah observance, has become the man of any woman's dreams!

She did not 'sign up' for this, but she most certainly did sign up for a caring, concerned, tolerant, respectful, and loving soulmate....

Be that.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Mar 10, 2009
Want to be religious and wife doesn't
We have the opposite in our family, I am the observant one, my husband not so. Our community gives him a great deal of respect knowing each person has theirindividual path. While at times,creating Shabbos and Yom Tov on my own leads me to be "oh poor me" , have caring friends who remind me of MY commitment to observance, and more importantly, to my spouse is a wonderful benefit. Our children, in their twenties, are in their own places from observant to clearly Jewish and proud of it.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Mar 8, 2009
Dear Lipa:
Thank you for your comment.

I'm quite distressed to hear of a family broken up because of religion. If it were truly a religious issue, then the family today would be intact.
I don't know, of course, the specific situation; nor do I know the rabbi who 'allowed' the breakup to occur. I can only tell you that the Torah way is that of shalom, not of destruction; shalom that is founded on mutual love and trust and respect between two adults, shalom that is founded in shared goals - that of meeting the best interests of the family. And, of course, each individual's need to be true to him/herself.
This is something all couples deal with...to say the family was broken up because of 'religious' reasons is, I believe, a fallacy.
Posted By Bronya Shaffer

Posted: Mar 7, 2009
Not the usual Chabad answer
I appreciate Bronya's reply to this question - that marriage comes first - and I wish it were that the answer that Chabad rabbis always give. Unfortunately it is not consistent with other situations I know of where a husband became observant under Chabad influence while his wife and children did not want to do so. In the case that I witnessed, the marriage of a quite nice family broke up and the Chabad rabbi allowed it to happen under the theory that the husband's personal observance trumped all other considerations. It was quite tragic to see and I thought it was irresponsible.
Posted By Lipa

Posted: Mar 4, 2009
related article
I am writing a magazine article on two-household families in which one parent is more observant than the other, or perhaps one is observant and one is not observant or even hostile to Jewish observance. I want to learn more about how the children involved are affected by the mixed messages. I also would like to know how the divorced parents handle this situation between them, keeping the kids' interests in mind. Any leads you can provide would be appreciated: hk@hillelthescribecommunications.com.
Posted By Hillel Kuttler, Baltimore, MD

Posted: Mar 3, 2009
Controlling
What happens when a woman is in G-d's will and is married to a man who, unintentionally, constantly tries to get her to live "his" way, in his definition of "normal" ?
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Mar 2, 2009
I really liked this article and I found it to be very helpful because I am going through the same thing but vice versa . I am the wife who is more religous than my husband.
Posted By Anonymous, great neck, n.y.

Posted: Mar 2, 2009
Husband is more religious than his wife.
Bronya is different than when he married. We don't know why he became "more observant." Notice he did not say "more religious." He appears to have made these life changes without his wife' consent or cooperation. There seems to be some resentment between husband and wife. He works long hours and he now spends time observing some Jewish rituals (not specified (despite the respondent's suppositions. I admire his desire to be more observant, but if this is going to create significant hostility in the family, he needs to observe those rituals which do not take time away from his family. His first commitment is to his wife and children. As long s the children are being raised with good Jewish values, it is less important at this point for them to become religiously observant. The wife must be careful not to criticize the father's observance in front of the children. If they wish to participate in the father's observances, they will let him know, and the wife must not stop them.
Posted By Stan Rose, Silver Spring, MD


 



By Bronya Shaffer   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Mrs. Bronya Shaffer is a noted globetrotting lecturer on Jewish women's issues, and serves as a personal counselor and mentor for women, couples and adolescents. Mrs. Shaffer, a responder for Chabad.org’s Ask the Rabbi service, lives with her ten children in Crown Heights, Brooklyn.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.