HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Blogs » Save this Marriage » Why Can't He/She Be More Like Me?








Save this Marriage
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment3 Comments

Why Can't He/She Be More Like Me?
Dealing with Gender Differences

In the ongoing effort to help couples – young and old – to come to a better understanding of what works in a relationship, it is always helpful to be in touch with the reality of our differences. Expectations always run high in any relationship. Whether or not those expectations are healthy is an important consideration in one's peace of mind.

But, the propensity of many to develop unhealthy expectations of their partner is often the result of real gender differences in the structure of the brain.

The phrase "it's all in your head" may actually hold more truth than we thought. For, although there obviously are cultural reasons for our differences in emotions and behavior, recent breakthrough research reveals that the root of many puzzling gender differences may lie in our brains.

Men's and women's brains have much in common, but they are definitely not the same—in size, structure or sensitivities. Actually a woman's brain, like her body, is 10-15% smaller than a man's. Yet, the areas of higher cognition, such as language, may be more densely packed with neurons. The corpus callosum, the bridge of fibers running down the center of the brain, is thicker in females, which may explain the "crosstalk" between the emotional, intuitive right hemisphere and the rational, factual left. Practically speaking, this translates often as the connections women make; a form of emotional intelligence, or intuition.

In school, even at a very early age, it has been documented that girls generally speak sooner and read faster than boys. They use neural regions on both sides of the brain, in contrast to males who draw mainly on the neural regions in the left hemisphere.

A woman's brain responds more intensely to emotion; melancholy feelings activate neurons in the brain in an area eight times larger in women than men. Is it any wonder that depression is twice as common in women as in men?

It also helps us understand why women are quicker to understand emotion; to recognize it in others, while it may take men a longer time – and they need more prompting – to notice and define a woman's mood.

On the other hand, men may be better able to focus intensely—which may explain why a man, for example, can immerse himself in a book or other activity to the exclusion of others things happening in the environment.

On the road, women pay more attention to what they see, particularly landmarks, like the synagogue, a friend's house or the playground. They rely on such landmarks to find their way, while men think in terms of direction and distance ("half a mile east, then south one mile"). This spatial perception also allows men, generally, to park a car more easily than women (sorry, ladies—that's what the research proves!).

At every age, women's memories outperform men's. Women associate names with faces (remember "connections"?) and they also are better at recalling lists. (Don't blame him if he goes to the store and can't remember what you need.)

Knowing these facts could go a long way to helping people understand the marital relationship that G‑d wants us to experience. He wanted us – both men and women – to be challenged to work hard at being loving, forgiving, patient and "judging to the side of merit."

This is especially true during times when we are stressed, and the expectations seem to rise automatically, making it even more difficult to excuse another person. During these moments, we need to dig deep inside to hold onto our perspective and maintain balance.

Here's an example of one typical issue that is a direct result of the differences between how than man's and woman's brain operates, and the woman's innate greater sensitivity to emotions:

A dynamic that I often encounter with couples is the wife's inability to state her needs factually, in a business-like manner, without negative emotion. A man often gets confused when too much emotion is expressed. He takes her anger/sadness/withdrawal, etc. as a sign of personal failure which causes him to either attack or withdraw. Often, he doesn't have a clue why she's so upset. And what often makes things worse is that following a heated interchange he may get through or get over the emotion quickly and move on.

Women, on the other hand, feel that the more emotion they invest in a request (even if it's a request for greater understanding), the quicker it will be accomplished. So they continue to escalate the emotion, thinking their objective will be met faster. In reality, all that happens is that the tension is maintained. In addition, women tend to hold on longer to their hurt feelings and are left wondering, "How could he so easily dismiss what happened? It doesn't seem fair!"

So practically, how are couples to deal with their natural differences?

For starters, couples should be on the alert for three counterproductive behaviors:

1. Mind Reading—thinking that your spouse should be able to read your mind and heart and know, intuitively, what pleases or displeases you.

2. Second Guessing—thinking, "He/she should have known better, should have called, should have been more respectful. (Words like "should, would, could" usually need to be investigated before believing!)

3. Assuming—thinking, "Sure I said I'd be ready in ten minutes; doesn't he know already that it would take longer?"

These three tendencies are all a result of the inherent differences between men and women, and the assumption that your spouse's mind works in the same way as yours.

In the following week(s?) we will focus on these behaviors, examine their roots, fallacies, and practical ways to avoid these marital pitfalls.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Jan 28, 2009
M/F differences
Before I read the prior comment about a woman teaching brides (and trying to explain to them the importance of understanding the natural differences between men and women) I was thinking that what Yehudis is saying here in this article should be REQUIRED a part of the traditional bride's class of how to observe the laws of family purity. So many first years of marriage could go smoother (and year #2, #3, etc.) Additionally, before older singles become "much older" singles, they should be taught about these differences, in a way that respects the 2 different ways of relating to the world. If you have impossible expectations before the first date, it's almost like writing off 1/2 the world's population!

Yehudis, keep up the great work, and looking forward to the future installlments of this series. You're really doing holy work!!
Posted By M.H., Yerushelayim/North Miami Beach, Israel/Florida

Posted: Jan 27, 2009
Men are From Mars...
It is very true that we shouldn't expect our spouses to read our minds, we don't expect friends to be able to read our minds. We also don't expect our friends to be everything to us, we have some friends to go our for tea, we have others that we talk to about the latest book we've read, or who will drop everything to take in a silly movie. Yet we expect our spouse to meet all our needs. One difference regarding emotions, is when we have a problem, we want to talk it out, our partner things we expect hin to solve the problem, if he can't he doesn't want to hear it, we just want him to empathize, not solve the problem. Regarding the directions: that he is better spatial concepts would be all lot more readily acceptable if they would just realize he doesn't know everything and ask for directions for crying out loud. We aren't challenging your manhood, we just want to stop driving around in circles. Sheeesh.
Posted By Rachel Garber, Phila, PA USA

Posted: Jan 27, 2009
Yehudis Karbal's article on M/F Differences
Thank You!!! I try to make the brides I teach aware of the natural differences in temperament between men and women, and that they are normal. But you have said it so eloquently, backed up by research.

A wonderful contribution to Sholom Bayis (marital harmony)!
Posted By Devorah L. Adler, Baltimore, MD


 



By Yehudis Karbal   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Yehudis Karbal, M.A. LCPC (Licensed Clinically Professional Counselor) is based in Chicago, but is available for phone-consultations.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.