HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Blogs » Let's Go For Coffee » The Questions that We Need to Ask








Let's Go For Coffee
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment3 Comments

The Questions that We Need to Ask
Tragedy in Mumbai

It's now a few days since we've heard the tragic news.

Almost like an addict, I still search for any new bits of news. News about the last hours of Rivka or Gaby's life. News about the terrorist groups. News about what could have been done differently to save precious lives.

Almost like an addict, I still search for any new bits of news

It's almost as if these little bits of information will somehow quieten the large and unanswerable questions that still roam freely in my mind. Big questions like WHY? How could it be? How can I resolve this ultimate paradox of paradoxes that seems to fly against everything I believed about the power of good triumphing over evil?

As I wrote in my previous blog, my youngest son, like children and adults the world over, was also greatly affected by this tragedy. He diligently recited hours of extra Psalms and took on as many good deeds as he could muster in the hope of a positive outcome, one that we now know was not meant to be.

There is much that we can learn from children's perspectives—from their intuitive, simple way of thinking. Sometimes, much more than even the deepest philosophies.

I assumed that once my son would hear of the terrible murders, he would be filled with questions and doubt--the types of questions that I was having. And the types of questions that I knew I wouldn't be able to find any answers for, because perhaps, in our exile world, there are no answers.

And, yes, my young but intelligent son did have questions. Many questions. And sad questions.

How are bodies transported in a plane?

But the types of questions that my son asked were unlike the ones that I had expected.

He asked things like:

Did two year old Moshe ever meet his grandparents before? Would he know them and feel comfortable with them?

How old were his grandparents? Were they young enough to have the strength and energy to take care of a young toddler?

When would the funeral take place? How are bodies transported in a plane?

At what age could a young orphan recite the kaddish prayer for his departed parents?

And finally, what were people doing? What campaigns were being started and what good deeds should be taken on in the merit of the Holtzbergs and all the other innocent, holy victims?

These were all difficult and painful questions that I tried to answer as best as I could.

But as I answered my son's questions it dawned on me that his questions were of an entirely different genre than my own. While my questions were in the realm of the theoretical and philosophical, his were entirely practical.

While mine were about "why", his were "how"," when" and "what."

In his simplicity, it was almost like my son intuitively realized that the type of questions that were haunting me were unanswerable, beyond what we can ever fathom, and need to be accepted at a faith level. So why waste our energy and efforts contemplating them?

Because while the "why" squanders our energy, the "how" empowers us to work harder.

While "why" provides an excuse for lethargy, the "how" propels us into action.

There's much we can learn from our children

While "why" lets us hide cowardly behind its depth and magnitude, the "how" demands us to bravely take small, functional steps to make change in our world.

Now is the time for all of us to ask questions. Many questions.

But the questions have to be of the nature that heroically bring more light into our world, rather than get us stuck spinelessly in its darkness.

We need to ask questions like how can we be of help, what can we do to brighten someone else's life and how can we increase joy and meaning in our world.


There's much we can learn from our children.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 3, 2008
THe Living G-d And The Ultimate Mitzvah
The living G-d the God of my father, of his namesake Issac, my ultimate ancestor, hears. Heaven too sheds tears and G-d listens, G-d cries and G-d acts. He will act for the sake of name and for the children. There is evil in the world but there is also incredible goodness. Moshe will understand one day his parents gave their lives not only for him but for divine merit, Kiddush Hashem. That is the greatest deed a Jew could ever do and it is the ultimate mitzvah. Jews love life but when it is necessary to die for G-d, its a statement that doing the right thing is ultimately its own reward.
Posted By Norman F Birnberg, Salida, CO/USA

Posted: Dec 3, 2008
questions w/out answers
Yes, Chana, you have put succinctly what is the only light we can find as we grope in the darkness. We must, even through our tears, and we SHALL move forth with our "how" - and empower others to move forth also- with a torch of light leading us out of the deep darkness of this bitter exile. Please, G-d, let it be today!
Posted By sara leah overlander, london, england

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
excellent
thanks
Posted By Chaya, Tsfat, Israel


 



By Chana Weisberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Chana Weisberg is a writer, editor and lecturer. She authored several books, including her latest, Tending the Garden: The Unique Gifts of the Jewish Woman. She has served as the dean of several women’s educational institutes, and lectures internationally on issues relating to women, faith, relationships and the Jewish soul.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.