HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Parenting
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » Parenting » Parenting & Education » Help! I've got kids... » Losers








Help! I've got kids...
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment3 Comments

Losers

You know who they are—children who lose everything: homework assignments, library books, mittens, wallets, hats, coats and scarves. "Here today, gone tomorrow" is their motto. An endless source of frustration for parents and teachers, "losers" are the most frustrated of all: they waste their own precious time and lose objects they value.

To add insult to injury, losers also get blamed for having ignoble character traits like "carelessness" or "laziness" when, in fact, they are suffering from a brain glitch. The ability to be organized and to remember where we put things is a process that can be affected only partially by conscious intent. We can certainly learn tricks and tools that will increase our recall, but our natural disposition for these activities is determined by brain functioning. Similarly, we can raise our intelligence scores by exposing ourselves to lots of stimuli – but only a little. Our inherent intelligence remains fairly constant. We can increase other traits by effort also – we can enhance our creativity and encourage certain talents, for instance – but only to some extent. Inherent ways of functioning are, well, inherent. We're born with them. Your organized child never taught himself to be that way; she was just born that way. Your child who suffers from strephosymbolia (reversal of letters and numbers) isn't doing that on purpose either – his brain is doing it for him. Similarly, the child who constantly forgets and loses things is suffering from a brain deficit—it isn't his fault!

What does this mean for you as a parent? Should you just give up trying to help your youngster do something he obviously can't do? No. There are, as I mentioned earlier, some tricks that you can teach your disorganized youngster that will help reduce losses. However, knowledge is power. Now that you know that the brain is responsible for this losing tendency, you won't be surprised when even your best "tricks" fail to produce consistently positive results. A better strategy than trying to outsmart the brain may be to teach your child to compensate for his deficit. He needs to work around it.

For instance, when adult losers have super-organized spouses or secretaries, they function better. Although your child isn't likely to have either of those advantages just yet, he can be taught how to enlist help or create systems to help prevent losses (as opposed to help strengthen memory networks). For instance, let's say a child has trouble getting the homework sheet home and then, if he managed to bring it home, rarely remembers to bring it back to school. It may be possible for the teacher to fax the homework to Mom and for Mom to fax back the completed assignment. Will this help Junior with his memory problem? Of course not! However, it will get his schoolwork done. This is an example of working around the problem. For important things like homework, this approach may be better than trying to cure what might in fact be an incurable brain glitch. However, Mom is free to continue to try, using other common losses like jackets, schoolbags and so on as the subjects of her efforts.

Why does G‑d give us brain glitches in the first place? We'll never know of course, but one reason that we can suggest is that the presence of imperfection can cause us to work on character traits like being judgmental and intolerant. Instead of screaming at our children for something that isn't even their fault, we can learn that G‑d makes different kinds of people with different kinds of strengths and weaknesses. Rather than get all judgmental about how "easy" it is to remember where one puts one's keys, we can work on developing our compassion and empathy for those who find it difficult. And since G‑d judges us midda k'neged midda (exactly the way we judge others), hopefully we will find ourselves experiencing more compassion from those around us for our own, very human, imperfections.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 11, 2008
I like this article....
Obviously, the author is referring to children (and adults) with AD/HD, but without the labels. What a nice way to approach this subject. As an ADHD mom raising an ADHD child, I found this an encouraging way to deal with the difficulties of organization.
Posted By Kathy Lipkin, Copley, OH

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Issues
I'm glad that you brought this issue up. It's important for parents and teachers to realize that sometimes it really is NOT a child's fault. This is true about many issues.

On the other hand, your solution is problematic. It puts far too much burden on the teacher. And, fax machines are not that common either.

Worse, it doesn't scale well and it totally takes the responsibility off the child. What the child needs to learn is a set of techniques that will help him (or her) work around the problem, ant to take responsibility. That would include reaching out for help, but that simply cannot be the whole of it.

So in the case of homework, a better solution is for the teacher to remind "Chaim" to put the assignment into his briefcase, the parents to remind him to put it back in his case when done, to develop a routine that makes it more automatic for the homework to be put in its place, and for the child to respond to reminders NOW, rather than "later".
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 23, 2008
losers
Although you make a very good and compassionate point, you neglected to mention that 4 letter problem........ADHD (or its sister, ADD) Yes, I know every anti-ritilin/concerta/adderal/etc. argument, and the pro-arguments as well, but sometimes its the answer. Also, a very easy and natural solution can be an increase of omega3 oil in the diet (fish oil, flax seed oil, etc) It does help, and studies show it doesn't cause any weight gain, either. Another "non-medical" treatment is a neurofeedback-related approach, called "Playattention." (check out their website, its worth looking into) Hashem puts these refuahs on the earth to help us, and certainly every parent wants to help their child be the best he or she can possibly be! There are never any guarantees for any refuah, but picking a good one, and davening for Hashem's help is the formula we must use.

Bottom line? We've all lost the most important thing for a Jew--the Bais Hamigdash, and the guaranteed cure? Moshiach!!
Posted By M.H., North MIami Beach/Yerushelayim, Florida/Israel


 



By Sara Chana Radcliffe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Sarah Chana Radcliffe, M.Ed.,C.Psych.Assoc. is the author of "Raise Your Kids without Raising Your Voice" and The Delicate Balance published by Targum Press. Click here to visit her website.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.