HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Blogs
 
Chabad.org » Blogs » Help! I've got kids... » Why We Yell








Help! I've got kids...

Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
15 Comments Posted

Why We Yell

Some people wonder why parents yell. Here's the logic:

Kids can be so maddening! You call them and call them and they don't come. You tell them and tell them and they don't listen! Sometimes you just have to yell to get them to pay attention. When you yell, they finally take you seriously.

Another good reason to yell is because it lets off steam. It is extremely frustrating to be running around all day, doing errands, going to work, running the household, taking care of everyone and THEN find that Junior's idea of a good time is to mercilessly tease the baby at bath time. How much can one mother take? Yelling prevents ulcers by releasing tension.

And by the way, we were yelled at plenty and nothing terrible happened to us. We're nice, well-adjusted members of society. O.K., maybe we don't have the greatest relationship with our parents, but hey, we turned out O.K.

Finally, we can't really help it. Yelling is born in our genes and raised in the models our parents provided. It's natural. Not yelling is not natural and takes way too much self-control – something like going off sugar, coffee and white flour for the rest of your life. If we weren't supposed to yell, our vocal chords would have been pre-set at mute.

So there you have it – the most common explanations (rationalizations?) for parental yelling. And although they all contain elements of truth, there is another side to the coin that must be considered:

The more we yell at kids, the more nervous habits they'll have. Hair pulling, nose picking, blinking, bed-wetting and other symptoms of stress increase the more parents yell. The more we yell, the worse the physical health of kids will be: more headaches, stomach aches, colds and flu's. The more we yell, the more behavioral problems our kids will tend to have: disobedience and defiance at home and/or school. The more we yell, the more social problems our kids will have: being victims, bullies, having trouble making and keeping friends. And the more we yell, the more distracted kids will tend to be when it comes to schoolwork. No one child from a yelling home falls apart in all these ways at once; each child's vulnerability will determine the area(s) of functioning that may be affected.

And there's more. If we yell at them for two decades straight (i.e. right through the teen years) then as adults they will tend to have: more personality disorders, more relationship problems, more depression and anxiety, more health problems, more parenting difficulties, more dysfunction of every possible kind.

The more we yell at our kids, the less they like us. The less they like us, the less they want to be like us. In not identifying with us, they may reject our teachings, our values and anything that we want to impart to them. Thus the more we yell, the less we can influence our children in the direction we want them to go. Passing on our Jewish heritage, teaching them right from wrong, imparting our most important lessons – our ability to do all of this is seriously threatened the more we yell at our kids.

Plus, chances are good that the kids we yell at frequently for two decades won't love us so much when they grow up and leave home. Some will never talk to us again. Some will move to the other side of the world and call only occasionally. Some will stay close enough to fight with us forever. We may or may not see our grandchildren. And our grandchildren are very likely to be yelled at because we've filled our kids' brains with the "yelling program." When we yell at our kids, we yell right down to the grandchildren and beyond.

So, while it's tempting to yell for all the reasons cited earlier, it's probably too high a price to pay for the gaining of a little cooperation. Fortunately, there are harmless and powerful alternatives for gaining a child's cooperation. They are worth the trouble to learn.


15 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Aug 10, 2008
I'm with those who would like some follow-up articles on how to act postively to get your child to listen or cop-operate or whatever it is. This article is very informative and well written but I found myself feeling terribly guilty about the times I have raised my voice but coming away with nothing really concrete on how not to.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Aug 8, 2008
Yelling
Rabbi Shmuel Lew was said that the Rebbe sent him a letter about dealing with his children. The Rebbe wrote that we are all children of G-d. By yelling at our children, we are yelling at the children of G-d...
Posted By Anonymous, Mequon, WI
via chabadmequon.org

Posted: Aug 6, 2008
I also agree with this line of reasoning.

For PK: Yes, explaining takes time and effort, but you end up with a very reasonable child. And sometimes the answer is "Because I said so." or "Because I am the parent." You can say this without yelling.

For young children touching them to get their attention helps. (Just a tap.)
Also they understand about radios, and tuning them in. So at a calm time explain that when they are not listening you are going to pretend they are like radios. You are going to touch them and say, "Tune into Mommy." That means they must find your signal. Make sure they look at you in response, and you know you have their attention.

For Elyakeem,
Nice idea, and I do get your point. But for several members of my family singing is the final threat!!! Our singing is that bad.
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI USA
via baischabad.com


 



By Sara Chana Radcliffe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Sarah Chana Radcliffe, M.Ed.,C.Psych.Assoc. is the author of "Raise Your Kids without Raising Your Voice" and The Delicate Balance published by Targum Press.Click here to visit her website.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.