HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Obama Phenomenon III








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment11 Comments

Obama Phenomenon III

His platform of change has got him past his first major hurdle. As of yesterday, Barack Obama clinched his party's presidential nomination. Since Day One, his detractors have accused him of having expressed very vague views on a host of domestic and foreign policy issues, instead basing his appeal on optimistic speeches, without providing much detail on how he would govern.

I have a theory. I think that he won the nomination not despite his ambiguity on the issues, but because of it. Proposing legislation and the outlining of detailed initiatives can not possibly compete with the utopian picture presented by the promise of "change." It is an intrinsic part of human nature to always be unsatisfied with the current situation. To always want more and better; to always yearn for change.

Had Mr. Obama based his campaign on a series of initiatives and a defined platform, his appeal would have been limited to those who approve of the proposed agenda. But the prospect of change talks to everyone—at least all those who are convinced of the sincerity of his intentions to really bring about change. And it excites one of the most basic human drives.

Brilliant campaign strategy? Apparently yes. Will he deliver if elected? Maybe. But one thing I can say with certainty. Even if elected, and even if he turns out to be a wonderful president, Obama will never satisfy our innate hankering for change. Accomplishing that will take much more effort on our part than pulling a lever in a voting booth.

Satisfying this need – on a personal as well as a global level – is possible. Every mitzvah we do brings closer the moment when the world will be changed for the good, once and for all.

If only all those who voted for Obama – both Jews and non-Jews – knew that their vote for change is perhaps a manifestation of their soul's deep desire for the ultimate change. The one that we can and will collectively accomplish; the one that will be ushered in by Moshiach.


11 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: June 20, 2008
Change
The president alone (whether it be Obama or not) cannot change the nation. We must all pitch in to see real change. The Rabbi is correct in saying that simply pulling a lever on Election Day is not enough. If we want real change we can't sit idly by and wait for it to come. We must act to bring it forth.
That's my $0.02.
Posted By Regina, NY, NY
via jewishharlem.com

Posted: June 17, 2008
change?
It is unfortunate that people are using this article to vent their personal political beliefs. I think Rabbi Silberberg was pointing out that wanting "change" is a natural human desire and we can use this force to change ourselves and world to make it a place where godliness can be revealed. As many commentators have pointed out, when people want "change", it can mean anything and everything. If your spouse wants a "change", it could mean divorce, a new couch, bigger house, a nice vacation, a new job, etc. Obama's success has been in tapping into this deep desire without specifically spelling out what he will change.
Posted By Anonymous, Fresno, CA

Posted: June 17, 2008
Obama
The change is a change in HOW this government functions or more correctly disfunctions. Simply put policy is driven by individual forces(lobbists) which collectively makes the total structure of the government. There is no overall vision or structure.
Posted By Anonymous, University Hts, Ohio

Posted: June 17, 2008
Political Satire
The thought of having Obama as the president of the United States of America can only reaffirm my believe in having Moshiach now for the sake of our nation.
Posted By Danny Schwartzman, Weston, Florida

Posted: June 15, 2008
Obama is a good man, this article is a joke
How sad to see some of the above comments, especially the one referring to 'whatever book he's sworn in on'.

Obama is not a Muslim. It is a shame some people still believe a ridiculous rumor.

In regards to the original article, it too lacks depth or evidence. Yes, Obama's campaign is about change, but Clinton used the phrase repeatedly as is McCain.

He has proposed important policy initiatives: universal health care, tax cuts for middle class, tax increases for those that make over $250,000 per year.

It is naive to pretend he has no policy issues just because he stands for change.

I'm embarassed Chabad has printed this article.
Posted By Reuven, Dallas, TX

Posted: June 15, 2008
Obama phenomenon III
Obma is a masterful speaker. That is his strength and that will probably be his legacy.
Posted By Anonymous, Morristown, NJ
via chabadcares.com

Posted: June 15, 2008
Obama Phenoma
You are correct that ambiguity has worked in favor of the Obama campaign. Now the question should be asked:WHAT will he deliver if elected? This must be made clear before the swearing in ceremony.(as well as what book he will be sworn in on) Change simply for the sake of change is sheer folly. Buying into this change idea is the same as buying a diamond from someone of questionable background - the buyer deserves what he gets...
Posted By Ya'acov Davis, Atlanta, Georgia

Posted: June 15, 2008
Change
Let's hope he is not elected. Change for change's sake is not always good especially when we already live in the best country. At conferences where there were psychologists I would object to the advice of psychologists. "Change your life" they said. I would point out that that was unwise because it overlooks that the client, if they took the advice, could lose their spouse, children, job, health, home, bank account. I would point out that a person has to weigh what will be gained, what will be lost. How many voters are doing that? Obama's solution is immature and is aimed at immature voters, regardless of age. How many of you would go under the knife with a plastic surgeon "for change's sake"? You wouldn't. You would want to see what the plans of the surgeon were. Who would say "whatever, it will be different." If people wouldn't do it to their face, why would they do it to their country? Why? The opposite of wisdom and if it happens it likely will be a very rude awakening.
Posted By Leah, Half Moon Bay, USA
via chabadbythesea.com

Posted: June 6, 2008
Your point is well taken Rabbi! I have searched the Text and see no command of God for change like the change of which Mr. Obama speaks. I do see a command to change one's garments. It also says, I am the Lord, I change not.

So one has to ask themselves it they believe they are like the Lord, why is change such a part of their driving desires?
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: June 6, 2008
Change What?
I agree that Obama's success is due to offering the hope of change, without giving any details to cause disagreement. Success does not keep me from being skeptical, however. I somehow fear that he won't deliver the change he promises, which is interesting, since change is always happening, and he has not described which change he intends to bring. I simply hope that his passionate followers will gain a desire to actually work for change if he can't do it himself.
Posted By David Burgess, Kansas City, Missouri


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.