HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Israeli "Aggression"








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment59 Comments

Israeli "Aggression"

There's an old joke about three people, one of them a member of the Israeli Defense Forces, who were shipwrecked and landed on a remote cannibal-infested island. They were captured before long, and as cauldrons of water were being hoisted on to the fire, the generous natives offered to grant each of their captives one last wish.

The first doomed man requested a pen and paper, and penned a farewell note to his family. The second person asked for a five-course –non-human-meat – final meal. The Israeli then asked that the tribal leader punch him in the face. A strange request, but in their final moments on earth, people don't always think coherently... As soon as the Chief socked him, the Israeli pulled out an Uzi and mowed down the hapless captors.

"Why did you wait until he punched you before shooting them?" the two relieved friends asked.

"And have the world say that I was the aggressor?!"


Nice joke, but, as I sadly learned this week, it does not at all reflect reality. It seems that regardless of how she is socked, any action Israel takes in self-defense will be viewed as "unwarranted aggression."

Reading the international reaction to the latest Israeli-Palestinian conflagration, I was unsure whether to laugh or cry.

U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon accused Israel of "disproportionate and excessive use of force." Israel's "close friend and ally," the "moderate" Mahmoud Abbas, used words like "genocide," "massacre," and "international terrorism" to describe Israel's actions. A statement issued by the EU condemned the "recent disproportionate use of force by the Israeli Defense Forces against the Palestinian population in Gaza." Saudi Arabia compared Israel's assault on the Gaza Strip to Nazi war crimes. Canada's Foreign Affairs Minister expressed concern about the Israeli retaliatory measures "because of their impact on civilians." And Pope Benedict called on "both Israelis and Palestinians" to unconditionally halt the violence.

The "moderate Palestinian" leadership based in the West Bank also suspended peace talks with Israel. The Palestinian representative to the United Nations explained that the Israeli attacks threaten to destabilize the region and "derail the peace process."

Wow.

After months and months of relative inaction in the face of daily rocket barrages, the Israeli government decided to take action to defend her people. The decision to act followed the death of a civilian in Sderot from Kassam fire, and the landing of rockets in Ashkelon, a southern city with a population of 100,000+.

So here's my question: We see that Israel will never have an acceptable "excuse" to pursue the terrorists and destroy their infrastructure and rocket factories. Such action will inevitably trigger universal condemnation. So why wait to be punched in the face before embarking on a self-defense mission?


59 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Jan 15, 2009
Response to Elizabeth
I myself am religious so please don't read frum bashing here. I agree that manipulation by elites isn't always easy to detect. For those that don't follow politics it can be a daunting task. However, the proof is in the details and timing. Israeli govts in the past have and continue to call upon outward foes at vrious junctures as a means of gaining points and settling issues with rivals. Why were rockets allowed to fly more then one time without a serious response. By the time they invaded patterns had been established. All Israelis should have been out on the streets after rocket one.
It is up to the various groups within Israel to stick to their guns. Nobpdy is picking on the Chasids or calling them "sheep." In fact they have rep. in the govt. and need to get tough and hold pols accountable.

The allure here is to demand facts and accountability from elected officials something that we all have to learn to do better aka 700 billion bail out.

thanks
Posted By David, Bronx, NY

Posted: Jan 15, 2009
Response to David
David, if what you are stating is true, then my heart goes out to the civilians of Israel who have to put up with the decision making body of the Israeli government. Please do not treat the intelligent, G-d fearing Jews like they are mere sheep. They are precious in the eyes of G-d.
Similarly, the Hasidic communities are simply ignored by such govts. Support their cause.

The election mania will cost Israel tremendously. They are learning the wickedness from the westerners.
If there is crisis in Israel, I blame the men that you have mentioned.
Posted By Elizabeth
via chabadofbakersfield.com

Posted: Jan 14, 2009
The politicval classes and their calculations
Unforntunately once again we see that the real issue is not with history, the bible, G-ds will and or the nations at conflict. No the real issue is with the calculations that those in power take rgeardless of consequences for thier own peoples or others. Look at the current crisis. Who are the real losers. The citizenry of israel and the Gazan's.
Why now did the politicos in Israel decide to act--isn't this the same Barack who got out of southern Lebanon? Now he is bellicose why? Ah, there is an election coming up and he doesn't want to lose to Bibi. He needs to be tough. The govt. was fine letting rockets fly for years. Why now?

Hamas ont heir end, why escalate now? Why not elevate pain and suffering of their peoples? Is ideology more important then human life?

lastly, why do the populations of these lands not throw out those bellciose forces and get t the real task at hand--eocnomics, the environment, education and peace.

This seems to be the most logical way to go!
Posted By David

Posted: Jan 14, 2009
Gaza
Israel serves a living G-D, no matter who criticizes, we will defend Israel if the need arises a grain of sand must not be given to the palestinians. Shalom
Posted By Uri, Ryd, KSA

Posted: Jan 13, 2009
Gaza hostilities
I too am angry with the biased reporting about the present situation in Gaza. However the high numbers of casualties Gaza citizens are experiencing will only add fuel to their hatred of Jews and the nation of Israel.

But for every man, woman or child that is injured or killed, there will be ten more recruits to perpetrate violence in the future. Maybe for some, no Palestinian is an innocent victim, as in the minds of Muslims, no Israeli is innocent. However is it time now to show mercy?

Hamas does not care about them, they use suffering to strengthen their evil cause.

God is just and merciful, should we not do the same? By showing compassion to your enemy, you will show how much more human you are than Hamas and similar groups.

Whatever Israel does it will be condemned by the majority. But I ask you the question, what does God want Israel to do?
Posted By Clive McLaren

Posted: Jan 13, 2009
Gaza
We Christians stand w/you...
we try to explain to people (who don't read the Bible) WHY the land belongs to Israel.
Ez.38:-39: soon????
I pray for the peace of Jerusalem.
.......GOD BLESS HIS PEOPLE........
Posted By Madeliene Jo Carrillo Ojeda, Norco, CA

Posted: Jan 10, 2009
Thanks Naptali
The world keeps saying Israel is occupying palestinian land, there is no Palestine and a grsin of sand must not be given to the palestinians Israel is an eternal inheritance to the childred of Yacov so anyone who does not want to see Israel's existense must go hand themselves. we are right behind the Jewish people, which country can tolerate the lobbying of missiles and otherprojectiles into its territory???? NON

Long livce the Jewish people, Long live Israel
Posted By Uri, Ryd, SA

Posted: Jan 8, 2009
Thank you Naftali
Who cares what they think? This should have been stopped 300 rockets ago but precious time was wated worrying about what the UN and others would think. I have some words for this General Ban Ki-Moon but unfortunately, I can't express them on this religious site...let me just say he can take a trip up a canal where the sun does not shine.
Posted By Anonymous, Weston, Fl

Posted: Jan 6, 2009
Reply to Karp
At the time Yisro was not an outsider. He converted but wasn't at Mount Sinai at the revelation and like Elizabeth stated above, Yisro believed in the G-d of Abraha, Issac, and Jacob and he made a "suggestion" to Moshe that was accepted and good for the Jewish people.
Posted By Tova

Posted: Jan 6, 2009
Response to Karp
Wasn't Yitro/Jethro (english version) the father-in-law of Moses? Since, Moshe married his daughter, the salvation came upon Yitro's household. Therefore, whatever Yitro said, should be taken into consideration. He believed in the G-d of Abraham, Issac, and Jacob. The rest of the world or the Palestinians do not follow the same G-d of Israel with the similar precepts.

So, don't go round and round trying to find faults in the workings of G-d's plan upon Israel.
Posted By Elizabeth
via chabadofbakersfield.com


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.