HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Why I Didn’t Vote








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

Why I Didn’t Vote

Submitted by Rabbi Menachem Posner, a good friend and a member of Chabad.org's "Ask the Rabbi" team.

Super Tuesday came and went and I stayed home.

Since I turned eighteen I have always taken the opportunity to exercise my right and duty to participate in the electoral process.

Why did I bother? Didn't I know that in overwhelmingly Democratic New York my lone conservative vote would never have any affect come the general election? Florida, Michigan…maybe, but New York?

I guess that my religious zeal carried over to my political philosophy.

Maimonides writes that every individual should view the universe as perched on a delicately balanced scale. Every small deed counts. One extra mitzvah and you've tipped the scale in a positive direction and Moshiach comes. One less mitzvah and…

That's why I always marched over to the old, red five-story holdover from the days before public schools needed to be wheelchair accessible or fire-safe, and signed my name on the dotted line.

But this year I didn't. I could say that it was because none of the contestants were particularly appealing. But, heck, I voted in those local elections when I chose candidates based on the number of syllables in their names! So why didn't I vote today?

I finally realized that politics is not religion. G‑d is infinite, so He can make my tiny actions important. But politicians can't. If my vote doesn't count, it's a waste of time and I don't have enough of that as it is.

But a mitzvah, even a small one, is not a waste of time at all.

Maybe one of the reasons why Menachem didn't vote is because he's getting married in less than a month. Mazal Tov! – N.S.


15 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Mar 4, 2012
vote
i disagree. the alternative may be having a portiz throw people in the dungeon without due process. we have rights and we should uphold them,
Posted By schneur, montreal, canada

Posted: Apr 28, 2008
Who will run the government?
John Adams wrote to his son: “Public business, my son, must always be done by somebody. It will be done by somebody or another. If wise men decline it, others will not; if honest men refuse it, others will not.”

Given the disappointing choices our parties are offering, perhaps it is time for some new blood. Any takers?
Posted By Tom

Posted: Apr 9, 2008
I didn't vote because...
I needed more time to make my decision and as well wanted to make sure that I know more about each candidate and what they stand for. I am afraid that I may have to give an account to G-d for my mistakes in electing one that has no fear of G-d; one that is exploiting mankind; one that is immoral, and leading the nations astray from G-dly precepts.

Take your time, folks! Don't get emotional.
Posted By Elizabeth
via chabadofbakersfield.com

Posted: Feb 10, 2008
Glad I'm in America
Blessed is G-d that we can participate in our nation's government and not have to worry about pogroms. Seems my family came here because of something like that.

While I have missed an election or two due to work or family obligations, I, like my father and brother before me, served in the armed forces of the US to say thank you for my freedom and the ability to practice my faith freely.

I think the rabbi should reconsider the effect of seeing an obviously religious Jew (the paisis give it away) go to vote on others in the community. It is part of belonging to the American community. Going to vote may even be a mitzvah.
Posted By Stuart, Princeton, New Jersey

Posted: Feb 10, 2008
To Mr. Papara
You chose to use highly inflammatory rhetoric in wording your "meta message", and while you definitely have the right to express your opinion, you had better get your facts straight if you're going to hit below the belt.

There is no obligation to vote. None. We have the right to vote. In your zeal to attack religion as the root of this evil, you have exxagerated the importance of the cause you promote.

You can draw your own conclusion regarding the "meta message" of your comment.
Posted By Moishele, Fort Dix, NJ

Posted: Feb 7, 2008
Wrong
Menachem, this is ludicrous. In a primary, it doesn't matter if your state is very liberal or very conservative, you're only voting for one party. Perhaps your argument would apply in a general election, but certainly not in this case.
Posted By The Real Shliach

Posted: Feb 7, 2008
Usually, even one vote counts
You chose FL and MI to say your vote would count. Not this year, the Dems won't seat/count our delegates at all, the Reps. will seat/count only half!!

But my first vote included a revote. In Ann Arbor, MI there was an area that was township, not city. Twelve people from that area were permitted to vote in the wrong place, casting votes for mayor, though they weren't residents. With a close vote count these were challenged, and the people were ordered to tell who they voted for. Eleven did. Then the votes were completely balanced. The last one said how any one person votes is secret, and should remain so. Also she did not remember her ultimate decision, even if she were inclined to say, she could not. This went all the way to the US Supreme Court. They found in her favor, how anyone votes is secret. The city had to redo the election.

To end confusion, the areas of Ann Arbor Township that were surrounded by AA City were incorporated into the city. No repeats!
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI USA

Posted: Feb 7, 2008
I disagree
I voted. Not because I thought that any issu would be decided by one vote. Rather, I voted because I was voting in favor of voting. One number that is important is how many of the registered voters turned out.

I would hate to have the powers that be think that I wasn't watching.
Posted By Ed Greenberg, San Jose, CA

Posted: Feb 6, 2008
The Rebbe: serial voter?
I've heard it said that the Rebbe would vote in every single election? Is this true? Is Rabbi Posner aware of this?

P.S. Isn't my subject line catchy? I bet images of dishonest vote-early-vote-often rabbis flashed across your minds! Just a little fun.
Posted By Levi

Posted: Feb 6, 2008
I blame Religion
Dear Joe from Idaho and Moishele,

Our author certainly has idealism, as evidenced by his devotion to the Torah lifestyle, but his idealism doesn't extend to his civic duties. Why not? Because his religious orientation focuses all his idealistic impulses towards Torah and mitzvos.

In everything there are messages and meta messages. The message of this post is: one vote is meaningless; one mitzvah is meaningful. The meta message is: because of my devotion to Torah I don't find it necessary to fulfill my civic obligations.
Posted By Joe Papara, once again


 



By Menachem Posner   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.