Contact Us
Cook It Kosher

S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches

S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches

 Email

Lag BaOmer, day of joy, celebration and bonfires, is almost upon us. And if you’ve ever sat around a bonfire, you’ve probably eaten something involving these ingredients . . .


It’s a simple equation: Graham crackers + marshmallows + chocolate + bonfire = S’mores. Now, if you’re a sworn traditionalist, read no further. But if you’re willing to embrace a decadent twist on the hallowed campfire concoction, read on and meet the deliciously cold S’more ice cream bar.


The recipe isn’t super-simple, but it’s also not hideously complicated. I made my own ice cream, but you can definitely use store-bought. I made the ice cream bars non-dairy, because I foresee serving them after a barbecue. But if your barbecues don’t involve meat, or if you plan on serving them with a dairy meal, feel free to use dairy ice cream.

We’re going to toast marshmallows and blend them into the ice cream. Then we’ll layer the ice cream with chocolate fudge sauce, and freeze on a flat tray. Next, we’ll cut the ice cream into squares, stick each piece between two graham crackers, and throw in an extra spoon or two of fudge for additional deliciousness (and to help it stick together).

So . . . are you ready to start?

The fudge sauce needs to sit in the refrigerator for at least two hours before we’re going to use it, so let’s begin with that. If you like to prepare in advance, this fudge is your friend. It lasts at least a week in the fridge, and possibly longer.


Measure the sugar, water, corn syrup and cocoa into a small saucepan. Cook over a low flame, mixing constantly. Within about five minutes, it should start to boil. Not a wild rolling boil, so you really need to keep an eye on it. Let it bubble for about one minute, making sure to stir constantly. Remove from the fire, add the vanilla, and stir. Refrigerate at least two hours before using.

While the fudge sauce is cooling and thickening in the fridge, it’s time to make the ice cream. I like to use coconut milk as my base for non-dairy ice creams, because most other recipes call for raw eggs and non-dairy creamer, both of which I prefer to avoid. If you don’t like coconut (and apparently 35% of people don’t!), you can definitely use any other non-dairy ice cream recipe instead.


Blend the coconut milk, sugar and vanilla until smooth. Keep it in the blender while you prepare the marshmallows. Spread them out on an ungreased cookie sheet, and turn the oven onto broil. I used mini-marshmallows, and they were ready after 1½ minutes. If you use the larger ones, or if your broiler is not as strong, you might need to go up to 2 minutes. Turn on the oven light, so you can peek through the window and make sure they don’t burn.


Scrape the melted marshmallows off the pan and into the blender. Blend until smooth. Pour the mixture into your ice cream maker, and process until thick and creamy. Take out your fudge sauce, a 9″ × 13″ pan and a large spoon. Layer the ice cream with the fudge sauce, without mixing them together. The goal is to have pockets of chocolate fudge between layers of white ice cream—not muddy brown ice cream. Make sure you leave at least ¼ of the fudge sauce for later. Freeze the ice cream until very firm (several hours or overnight).

If you’re using store-bought ice cream, let it partially defrost, and then use the same technique to layer it with the fudge sauce.

Now it’s time to put the sandwiches together.


Break your graham crackers in half. Cut the ice cream into squares. On each graham cracker half, put a spoonful of fudge, a piece of ice cream, another spoonful of fudge, and top with a graham cracker. Assemble the sandwiches quickly, so the ice cream doesn’t melt and make a big, sticky, gooey mess. Return the sandwiches to the freezer as quickly as possible. Store in the freezer until serving.

Most importantly . . . don’t forget to snag one for yourself before your friends and family polish them all off!


Fudge Sauce Ingredients:

  • ½ cup white sugar
  • ⅓ cup light corn syrup
  • ½ cup water
  • 6 tablespoons cocoa
  • 2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract

Directions:

  1. In a small saucepan, stir the sugar, corn syrup, water and cocoa together.
  2. Stir constantly until the mixture begins to boil. Continue stirring while it bubbles for one full minute.
  3. Remove from fire and add the vanilla.
  4. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours before using.

Marshmallow Ice Cream Ingredients:

  • 2 cans coconut milk (14 oz. each)
  • ¼ cup white sugar
  • 2 tablespoons vanilla extract
  • 1 8-oz. bag of marshmallows
  • 12 graham crackers

Directions:

  1. Blend coconut milk, sugar and vanilla.
  2. Broil marshmallows for 1½ minutes until brown and gooey.
  3. Add marshmallows to ice cream mixture and blend again.
  4. Pour into ice cream maker and process until mixture is thick and creamy.
  5. Layer the ice cream with the fudge sauce (do not mix!), and freeze until firm.
  6. Cut the ice cream into squares, and assemble. Put a spoonful of fudge on each half graham cracker, then a square of ice cream, then another spoon of fudge, and then another half graham cracker.

Feeling overwhelmed by all the steps in this recipe? Try this easy alternative. Use a graham cracker pie crust. Prepare the fudge and the ice cream, and freeze them in layers inside the crust. Freeze until serving. All the flavors with less work!

Do you like S’mores? What else do you associate with campfires? Share a bonfire memory in the comment section below.



Miriam Szokovski is the author of the historical novel Exiled Down Under, and a member of the Chabad.org editorial team. She shares her love of cooking, baking and food photography on Chabad.org’s food blog, Cook It Kosher.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
10 Comments
1000 characters remaining
Anonymous CA May 8, 2015

I just got kosher marshmallows at whole foods, but am sure they will have them at Smart and Finale. Can you buy ice cream instead of making? Reply

Anonymous CA May 6, 2015

kosher smores? Whole Foods and mothers or sprouts has kosher marshmallows, mini and big. Reply

Miriam Szokovski August 19, 2013

Kosher Marshmallows Hi L. Rut,

I am not familiar with particular stores in California, but if you can't find them in a store near you, you can order them online. Amazon has them, as well as some of the kosher grocery websites. You can use regular marshmallows for the exact same result as the minis.

Best of luck! Reply

L. Rut Bell, Ca. August 16, 2013

kosher smores? Just a quick question. Are you using Kosher marshmallows? Most of them contain gelatin. I found some in the Manishevitz brand, yet they are not easy to find. I live in Ca. where is there a good place to find the? Any help is appreciated, for my kids loved the, but they must wait until I can get a hand on Kosher marshmallows. Reply

Rishe bklyn May 1, 2013

did it came out magnificent
thank you, miriam Reply

Miriam Szokovski April 30, 2013

Reason for the extra step Hi Hadassah - I found the ice cream too soft to put directly in the sandwich without freezing first, but if you try it - let me know how it comes out! Reply

Miriam Szokovski April 30, 2013

Thank you! Thank you David and Nechama for the great feedback. We are working on a Pinterest button - stay tuned! Reply

Hadassah Nmb April 29, 2013

extra step? why do bother to freeze the ice cream separately. I would just layer it in the graham crackers and freeze right away? Reply

nechama stamford,ct April 26, 2013

pinterest? Please put a pinterest button on this so i can post it. What a great idea!! Reply

David Calabretta WHITEFISH April 25, 2013

Moore Smores! Dear Lady you are the bomb! And I mean that in the best way. My eyes were delighted to see these wonderful deserts.

Thank you,

David Reply

Cook It Kosher features recipes from Chabad.org food blogger Miriam Szokovski, as well as guest bloggers and cookbook authors. Let us know if you’d like to contribute!
Miriam SzokovskiMiriam Szokovski is the author of the historical novel Exiled Down Under, and a member of the Chabad.org editorial team. She shares her love of cooking, baking and food photography on Chabad.org’s food blog, Cook It Kosher.
Recent Posts
Blog Archive
Related Topics