HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Contemporary Voices
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Daily Life » Musing for Meaning » Being Other-Centered








Musing for Meaning
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

Being Other-Centered

When I was twenty-three, I was hired as an adjunct lecturer at Brooklyn College to teach Composition. My only previous teaching experience had been with high-school seniors, and I wasn’t quite sure what I was in for.

The first day of class, I entered the room and quickly surmised that I was by far the youngest one there. And if I wasn’t, I certainly looked it. Being that Brooklyn College has a lot of returning students and students from around the world, the room was filled with every age, nationality, culture and religion you could imagine.

No one even noticed me standing at the deskFor the first minute, no one even noticed me standing at the desk. Then, when they did, they couldn’t believe I was their instructor. “Are you kidding me?” “She looks like she’s sixteen!”

Not a great start.

I introduced myself to rolling eyes, slouched bodies, heads on desks, and utter boredom and lack of interest about ten seconds into their very first class.

Then I told them to take out a piece of paper. On one side, they were supposed to write exactly how they were feeling at that moment. I told them to be honest. Brutally honest. Smiles appeared and pens moved.

Then I asked them to flip the paper over. On the other, they were to write exactly how they thought I was feeling at the moment.

And everything changed.

As soon as they had to think about me as a person—with feelings, with insecurities—it all shifted. If they were bored, I was nervous. If they didn’t want to be there, I was pressured to make them interested. If they didn’t think I looked old enough or experienced enough to do the job, I had to prove to them I was qualified. They quickly realized that as bad as they had it, I had it a lot worse. I was not the enemy . . . I was just standing on the other side of the room.

In this week’s Torah portion of Lech Lecha, we learn of Abraham needing to leave his home, to go out. Chassidic commentaries explain that we should understand lech, “go,” and then lecha, “to yourself,” as “Go and find yourself.” And how true that is. But I think there is another lesson as well. If we want to truly find ourselves, and truly connect with others, we need to go outside of ourselves while simultaneously letting others inside. In order to relate, we must feel.

In order to relate, we must feelThis is the difference between sympathy and empathy. If I sympathize with you, I feel sorry for you. Yet if I can empathize, I don’t just feel sorry for your pain, I feel your pain. It is a part of me. We are on the same team.

This is why the word for empathy in Hebrew is rachamim (and why the month of Elul is called chodesh harachamim, the month of empathy). The root of rachamim is rechem, which means “womb.” To understand you, to relate to you, to have a relationship with you, I need to be able to put you at my center. To be other-centered when needed to feel what you feel, think as you think.

It’s not necessarily easy. But it works. Trust me.

(And to all my teachers at whom I rolled my eyes, in front of whom I passed notes, and behind whose backs I did worse . . . I am truly sorry!)


15 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Nov 9, 2011
acts of hate - nov 8 2011
An earthquake is one idea to eradicate hate. G-d said that there would not be another Flood to wipe out the world.

If the forces of evil continue to outmaneuver the forces of good, and attract greater numbers of the disenfranchised, something has to give. If criticism continues to outflank praise, something has to give.

Changing the curriculum of hate would be a great start. Educating the illiterate masses away from fundamentalism would be a great start. Making crime not lucrative would be good. Eliminating corruption in ant form would be good. How often world wide do we see leaders promise to do one thing, and get our vote only to see them not follow through ? More often than not. It may not take a worldwide earthquake to improve things,, but it would have to be something like it.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 8, 2011
acts of hate
are very difficult to counter-act. It seems like a problem in which cutting one limb, creates as in gardening, more vigor when it comes to the spread of hate, as in, energy devoted to production of more limbs.

I think we are really in "limbo" when it comes to figuring out this problem because we must defend and protect our families as best we can.

It seems there has to be a sea change in consciousness that will of necessity sweep the world, to inculcate values of love, not hate, and to banish this notion of doing evil, as a solution to problems of humanity.

People who hate band together in that hate, and this kind of strength is toxic.

I know children must learn about compassion but their parents, their "gods" must be somehow turned around, to stop teaching about enmity and "the other". People are not born hating. Mostly, it's taught..

Do we need an earthquake to put people together so they work to save each other and by so doing realize a common humanity and love for each other?
Posted By ruth housman, marshfield hills, ma

Posted: Nov 6, 2011
Great question - nov. 6 2011
How do we get to the roots of such evil acts ?

i have no intention to sidetrack this beautiful article. my point was to be ready to be ' other- centered ' almost always, but to be vigilant where evil exists, as it surely does.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 6, 2011
suicide bombers
are not acting out of any sense of morality and of course this must be stopped as people cannot and should not tolerate inhumanity being horrific acts. Sadly hate is taught and the very notion there is religious right in this is a total distortion. How do we get to the roots of such evil acts. Immolation only serves to ignite terror and the need for self defense. It is impossible to imagine that there is an ethics that condones this.
Posted By ruth housman, marshfield, ma

Posted: Nov 4, 2011
the other side
By the other side i refer to the other individual who is wont to do evil. A suicide bomber exploding a device in a cafe in Jerusalem is to be condemned and actions taken in the swiftest way. This may be contrary to the topic, but the idea of empathy must be weighed cautiously from time to time. Madoff is not deserving of empathy, just the opposite.These ne'er -do-wells do exist, and one must not be Pollyanne-ish about it.

I love the article. 9 times out of 10 it should work.That 1 time out of 10 that it fails is optimistic on my scale.
Posted By Anonymous, w

Posted: Nov 4, 2011
from Cat Spring, Tx
Louise, your words are beautiful. This is such a poetic way of seeing and I feel you are quite right.
Posted By ruth housman, marshfield, ma

Posted: Nov 3, 2011
Empathy centered ... G_d and Us
Relating this to the Shema (Shema Yirael echad Elohim) ... G_d's goal is to write His instructions, laws, etc on our heart (Jeremiah 31:31 - 34). In this way He will be in our heart, in our "center", and we will be able to think and act more like Him. We will develop oneness with Him. Only then can we fully develop oneness with others in the world. Think of the circle that Jane Sapp (the lady from Georgia) uses. One person in the center and others circled around them: When G_d is in the center of the circle of His people Israel, with His Instructions on our heart (our center), and we model Him, then He will show all of us how to have complete empathy, forgiveness and harmony with others in the world. He and His instructions and laws are the perfect model of empathy.
Posted By Louie Modling, Cat Spring, TX

Posted: Nov 3, 2011
the middle school years
During the teenage years 13-ush through to 15 -ish a teacher must be aware that students, mainly boys but not only, do not have a sense of fair play. Those types are apt to reply to the how does the teacher feel with the note; " Who cares ?! " Hormones are running wild, and pimples are their biggest worry.

That said, this article is fabulous. Empathy does not always come naturally. Empathy is that mitzvah to love others. Like all mitzvot, empathy is just the right thing to do.

Yasher koach !
Posted By Anonymous, w

Posted: Nov 2, 2011
Great article and perspective
I will share this with the teachers I know.
There is a lot of bullying at my workplace. I always think that if the bullies would stop to consider that this is someone's wife, father or whatever that they are disrespecting; if they would think what it would be liked for someone they are close to to be bulled; and if they had to behave like that in front of the person's nearest and dearest then maybe the bullying would end.
Posted By Denise Rootenberg, Toronto

Posted: Nov 2, 2011
Thank you!
Please know that even if I don't always respond, I always read the comments and am so appreciative of them.!
Posted By Sara Esther Crispe, Merion Station, Pennsylvania


 



By Sara Esther Crispe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.