HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Mark Madoff's Tragedy








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment36 Comments

Mark Madoff's Tragedy
How Words Can Kill

Mark Madoff
Mark Madoff

The headlines scream, "Madoff's latest victim" and indeed it is. Just hours ago we read how Mark, the married father of two children, hanged himself in his apartment while his baby slept in another room.

I can't imagine how desperate, despondent and hopeless this man could have felt to take his own life while his beloved two-year-old baby was there. Wasn't he concerned that his son could have woken up and found him? He did email his wife, who was out of town with his older child, alerting her that someone should check on the baby, but what if she hadn't seen that email for a number of hours? I simply find it incomprehensible. But then again, desperation usually leads to incomprehensible outcomes.

Suicide is always tragic. It is always heart wrenching. And it is ultimately a punishment not to the one who felt he didn't deserve to live, but for all those survivors who have to suffer with the guilt, the "what-ifs" and the lack of closure from such a loss.

But this particular suicide does not seem like it was an indirect punishment to those closest to him, but rather a very calculated one. By no means do I think it was coincidental that Madoff's son took his life two years to the day that his father was arrested for the biggest Ponzi scheme in history.

Mark Madoff's lawyer came out with the following statement following the confirmation of suicide:

"Mark was an innocent victim of his father's monstrous crime who succumbed to two years of unrelenting pressure from false accusations and innuendo," said Martin Flumenbaum, an attorney representing Mark and his brother Andrew.

I don't know about you, but I don't know anything about Mark Madoff. But I do know that just because his father was a corrupt, dishonest and immoral person, does not make his son one. And I also know that the anger, bitterness and hatred that must have been directed at the eldest son of such a character could not have been easy to live with. Clearly, Mark felt it was impossible to live with it.

Judaism recognizes the power of speech, both in terms of building a person up and likewise, in its ability to completely destroy. In Proverbs it states: Mavet v'chayim beyad halashon, "Life and death are in the hands of one's speech," (18:21). This is why there are numerous laws dedicated to shmirat halashon, guarding one's speech. Even more so, the commentaries explain that to publicly humiliate a person is akin to killing that person. For when someone loses their self respect to the extent that he or she cannot face others, that is likened to taking away that person's lifeline.

It was just a few weeks ago that we read in the Torah portion, Vayeshev, of the story of Yehuda and Tamar. Tamar was about to be executed for a crime she didn't even commit. She could have exonerated herself, but in doing so it would have caused grave humiliation to Yehuda. So instead she gave him the opportunity to speak up for himself. From this the Talmud explains that one should go to great extents to avoid embarrassing another.

Another case in which a woman taught us this lesson was with Rachel who was to be married to Jacob. Her corrupt father tried to switch her older sister, Leah, for the bride. Knowing this could happen, Rachel and her groom came up with special signs so that he would know if he was marrying the right woman. But Rachel couldn't go through with it. She couldn't put her sister through the utter humiliation of being detected under the major canopy. It wasn't Leah's plan to marry Jacob, it was her father's, so why should she have to suffer being found out? Rachel knew that embarrassing her sister like that that was tantamount to killing her. And so she had the self sacrifice to preserve her self respect, her life.

Mark Madoff turned his father in. He was never accused of any crime, nor has there been any proof that he was complicit or aware of his father's actions. And yet, time and time again he was brutally accused and blamed in the media. He was an easy target. His father clearly didn't care who he hurt or the pain he caused. His father is sitting in prison and doesn't need to face all those whose lives he destroyed. But Mark had to live out his father's true punishment; the day to day anger and rage that his father caused so many.

Bernie Madoff was certainly punished today. He lost his eldest son and regardless of how cold and callous he has been, there is no question that the deep pain and void will be overwhelming. But did anyone win? Is anyone satisfied? Did anyone want two little children to grow up without a father and for the youngest to one day realize he was in the next room when his father took his life? That this boy will always wonder how he was not enough to keep his father alive?

There is no question that every person, reporter, source or writer that lashed out against Mark Madoff was furious. But was Mark Madoff really the target? Was he the one deserving of those comments? We have a judicial system for a reason. And it is predicated on the concept that one is innocent until proven guilty. Not guilty until he can prove his innocence. And even when guilty, it is the court that decides the punishment, not the public.

Yet in today's day and age we don't need to wait for the courtroom to decide one's verdict. Through the blogsphere, social networking, email and web news we can pass judgment and give a life sentence in seconds. It doesn't take long for a rumor to spread. And yet, it can take a lifetime for the truth to come out and give someone back the dignity deserved.

According to the Torah commentaries, the distinguishing difference between us and animals is that we have the ability to speak. Human beings are called a "medaber" a speaker, for our speech allows us to share our innermost thoughts and feelings with another. Only through speech are we able to connect. Yet we must never forget how powerful our words are and the impact they can have.

Unfortunately, it seems that it was the misuse of speech that caused unending and unyielding pressure on Mark Madoff. Our words became the judge, jury and verdict. And today unfortunately, we unknowingly and unwillingly gave him a death sentence.


36 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Apr 18, 2011
When you assume...
I just wanted to point out that everybody, author and commentators alike, seems to believe 100% that he was innocent. You don't know whether he was or wasn't. You weren't there, and even if you were, you don't know what his mens rea was during the time the atrocities were committed. Nor do you know what else was going on in his life. You should not judge him OR his father for his death. Leave that work to G-d.
Posted By Anonymous, Blacksburg, VA

Posted: Apr 14, 2011
Hi i could not agree with you more, it is very that human nature is as such, that instead of being fair to others, we often allows our biases to determine our behaviours to others, i am from New Zealand, a few years our minister of justice, in order to win vote for the party in the coming election, he actually went on the media and stated that he does not think the principle "innocent unitl proven guilty" is appropriate, i remember when i heard that on tv, i cant tell you how shocked and dissapointed that how low our politician would go to win votes, i cant imagine how a person would get to a point in their life where they could go against their own conscience like that. anyway, like you pointed out, it is all the slander and rumour perpetuated by people who rather lead by their emotions than sense of integrity that ultimately killed mark madoff, and left his two kids without a dad, my heart goes out to his wife and kids.
Posted By Anonymous, Christchurch

Posted: Dec 16, 2010
Mark Madoff's Tragedy
The comments on Sara Crispe's thoughtful and learned article are revelatory. Try to imagine what the comments would be if this self-killing occurred in 1960, a half-century earlier. The arrogance and judgmental remarks of most of the commentators would simply be unthinkable. Everyone wants to be the smartest kid on the block. "Boruch Dayan Emet" used to be sufficient. Thank you Sara Crispe for the sustained tone of respect which are fitting. The rest of the commentators should spend a Shabbos with a Chabad family for a lesson in modesty and proper speech. Not for nothing does Chabad emphasize the interconnectedness of Thought, Speech and Action.
Posted By Bruce Kowal, Bayonne, NJ

Posted: Dec 16, 2010
Anonymous
Not sure why he didn't leave the country. Like go to israel? If he wasn't under investigation and couldn't find a job and wanted to unburden himself from his past I would think Israel would be the perfect place to go.
Posted By Anonymous, Seattle, WA

Posted: Dec 15, 2010
Lifeline
Was Mark all alone with his demons ?

I don't know. There was no suicide note.

Sometimes the value system of an individual cannot cope, despite lifelines. It is not only in matters of suicide, but also homeless, mental health, bullying, and other situations i cannot even imagine.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 15, 2010
who are we ?
30 comments hot off the press. I don't see one from a victim of the robbery. If Bernie put you in the poorhouse, how would you feel ? Responses by victims to the press after the initial shock was mixed. Bernie Madoff stabbed/robbed many in the back. Easy to say money isn't everything when you are not the victim. Mark continues a sensational story. The Diana incident was colossal for the media.

Just like with OJ Simpson, there is a court of law and then there is the court of public opinion. It seems that Bernie got off too lightly in the mind of the ' public '/prosecutors. Whatever demons went after Mark will continue to go after family and accomplices. A combination of mob mentality, media frenzy/sensationalism.

Loshon Hora is robbery in three parts; robs speaker, robs listener and robs victim. Unfortunately in this instance, it seems necessary to re-repeat the harsh lesson: Thou Shalt Not Steal.

All that said, I am deeply sorry for Mark and his immediate family.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 15, 2010
empathy?
The feelings of others was completely missed by Bernie Madoff and whoever participated with him. The idea is not to believe everyone who comes to you with a deal too good to be true. Obviously these people who used people for their own profit did not care about the feelings of others. Those wolves are everywhere and the buyer beware. That is the lesson to teach our children.
Posted By Mrs. Catherine Cronin

Posted: Dec 15, 2010
G-d forgot
When Sara was told about Isaac's sacrifice, she died of shock. That sent a message to G-d to be careful not to overwhelm people with His challenges. I do not think that G-d gave Mark enough protection.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 15, 2010
very powerful message
how many times must we ask ourselves, are we bullies? do we at times unwittingly crush the feelings of others....
Or are we accomplices to these crimes due to lack of self confidence etc...
how many innocent victims have died or had nervous breakdowns and the like due to our callousness.
We must teach our children empathy and the determination and responsibility to stand for the feelings of others!
Posted By nosson, Beijing, Beijing Shi

Posted: Dec 14, 2010
Mark Madoff's unbearable pain
Thank you for this thoughtful and important blog post. Like someone who left a previous comment, I have been killed by someone's slanderous, evil words. A Jewish Florida businessman accused me of being anti-Semitic--knowing that I'm Jewish, born and raised.

He published it everywhere, contacting customers, associates and every dealer in our industry, trying to put me out of business. I have to live with it to this day.
Posted By Steven Cyrkin, Costa Mesa, CA


 



By Sara Esther Crispe   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Sara Esther Crispe, a writer, inspirational speaker and mother of four, is the editor of TheJewishWoman.org and writes the popular weekly blog, Musing for Meaning. To book Sara Esther for a speaking engagement, please click here.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.