HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Where I Stand on Health Care Reform








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment6 Comments

Where I Stand on Health Care Reform

So, earlier today a smiling President Obama signed into law the landmark health-care overhaul bill that was passed by the House this past Sunday night. If the polls I've seen are to be believed, nearly half of you are overjoyed by the bill's passage, while slightly more of you are outraged.

I'll get to my thoughts on the bill in a moment (I love building up the suspense...), but first I'd like to discuss my feelings about the individual who tirelessly spearheaded the year-long political battle that led to this moment.

It wasn't long ago that Mr. Obama was enjoying widespread public support and enviable ratings in the opinion polls. Over the past fifteen months, however, that broad backing has slowly waned.

In addition, the opposition, in a surprising display of unity, came out firing on all cylinders against this health care overhaul. Many citizens were persuaded by these arguments, even resulting in quite a few Democratic representatives voting against the bill—perhaps fearing that a vote in favor would translate into votes against in the upcoming elections.

As a rule, once "common wisdom" declares something to be a lost cause, elected officials are quick to wash their hands of it. No politician can afford to be associated with failure. And common wisdom, up until almost the very end, had deemed the health care bill's chances of passing as slim.

Yet, despite it all, the President persevered. And by the skin of his teeth – by a majority of only seven votes – the sweeping health care reform was passed into law.

Obviously, the President strongly believes in the importance of this cause. And to his credit, he didn't give up once the going got tough. Democracy notwithstanding, a true leader who is given a mandate must have the courage to run with the ball, also in face of the ever-vacillating see-saw of public opinion.

What an appropriate message for these pre-Passover days. On Passover, we try to liberate ourselves from our personal restricting "Egypts." We need to make bold decisions and commit ourselves to reaching the finish line—without regard for what others might say or think. We must all be real leaders—starting with charting the paths of our own lives.


As for the bill itself, I'm opinionless.

Honest to goodness. This is not an attempt on my part to evade giving a political opinion (something which perhaps I've been guilty of in the past), but the honest truth.

In principle, I'm all for universal health care. I strongly feel that a nation that has the means to do so – as ours does – should ensure that no citizen goes without adequate medical care due to inability to afford it (for more on this topic, see The Blessing of Rising Healthcare Costs). But this particular bill: will it bring relief to the needy, or will it – as the Republicans claim – serve to hopelessly bankrupt insurance companies and even our nation, lead to a government takeover of the health care system, and cause a drastic decline in the quality of our medical care?

I don't know.

The bill is more than 1,000 pages long, and written in language mostly incomprehensible to the average Joe (which happens to be one of my nicknames). In fact, from what I understand, the bill cannot be meaningfully read from front to back, because its tenth title is a list of amendments to the previous nine titles, which must be applied to the titles and sections to which they refer before the bill can be interpreted properly...

And then, to fully understand its impact would necessitate a study of the bill's assessment by the Congressional Budget Office (a mere 36 pages).

So, my opinion? I cry uncle!

Nevertheless, it seems that there is no shortage of people who have very strong opinions about the bill—both pro and con. Which leaves two options: a) They're all way brighter than me, and have much more time on their hands. b) Their opinions are largely based on what their spouse/father/pundit-sister-in-law says, ingrained political affiliation, or a few CNN or FOX sound-bites.

I suspect that the latter option is the one most often true.

Where am I going with all this?

I think it behooves us all to reexamine many of our perceptions and beliefs, and to ask ourselves: how may of them are based on real information and data, and how many of them have we simply absorbed from our environment? And how many of these opinions are we incapable of honestly evaluating because we lack the skills?

We all have opinions about ourselves, what we can and can't, should and shouldn't do; about others; about religion and spirituality (exactly what is a spiritual act or lifestyle?); and every other area in life. If we truly want to be liberated this Passover, we must take the time to develop substantiated opinions and values.

And for us Jews, this quest starts at home. We have a 3,300 year old system of wisdom, values, and principles.

What's your opinion on your heritage?


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Mar 27, 2010
Healthcare Bill
I have to agree with Paul Donen. The end never justifies the means. If the bill is so great why all the shenanigans to get it passed? Why not disclose what is in it in simple terms in a few pages instead of over 2000 pages of govspeak? Why did Nancy Pelosi say "pass the bill then you will see what is in it"? Without knowing specifically what is in it I would assume that being a product of people of poor character it is most likely not good. The analogy with the Golden Calf is very appropriate here. The majority is not always right. In fact they are more often wrong.
Posted By Chaim, DC

Posted: Mar 26, 2010
Well Said!
What a well-written article on the Health Care Bill. The first I've seen or heard that focuses on the perseverance, gumption and faithfulness of President Obama to produce reform that he wholeheartedly believes is necessary and which he has promised the American people from the start he would strive to achieve. I support the bill based on my belief that everyone has an undeniable right to affordable health care; and based on personal trials of dealing with health insurance struggles, increasing medical needs as well as costs, and a preexisting progressive disease-circumstances myself and other close friends are facing. I'm also adult enough to admit that I'm not willing to use the restricted energies and resources I have to read and comprehend any portion of the bill on my own or to derive an opinion based on some other media or individual's or poll's likewise inadequately informed interpretations. That's what we elect our government officials to do.
Posted By Diana, St. Louis, MO

Posted: Mar 26, 2010
Healthcare/Golden Calf
Aaron collected "taxes" (gold jewelry) from the people. The nation believed that G-d had forgotten them and THEY should have a god of their creation.
There are none so blind as they who refuse to see. The video by Mendel Kaplan, "The Sin of the Golden Calf," is revealing. It can be found in the Chabad TV videos.
Posted By Mr. Jim Rook

Posted: Mar 25, 2010
Health Care for All - The Common Good
I am pleased that this bill will serve the millions of our citizens who deserve the ability to see a Dr, and afford a health care plan. It's a start and by no means perfect, much like Social Security and Medicare that also was argued by the opposition - would ruin the economy and lead to a communist order. I would rather have my tax dollars go the Common Good of our fellow man, then to the "War Machine" , the billions that have been spent to kill millions of people and enriched the coffers of the Corporations that support the Military Industrial Complex that President Eisenhower warned the nation about over 50 years ago. Those who argue against Reform are also those who benefit from the Health Insurance, and Big Pharma Companies that have funneled millions of dollars to the lobbyists and politicians that do not want ANY reform. It's not about personal freedom, it's about MONEY at the cost of human illness and suffering. It's immoral to continue the status quo.
Posted By Bubbie Rose, Seattle, WA

Posted: Mar 25, 2010
The Healthcare bill
As G_d's chosen left Egypt and traversed thru the wilderness, collectively they were no different than us today. At times they celebrated their freedom and at other times they longed for "government control" of their lives. Though in servitude at least they had food. They desired to "depend" on worldly government instead of G_d.
This bill is much the same. It appeals to the physical being instead of the spiritual self. If I know someone is in need, insurance or otherwise, it is my spiritual duty to act as a servant of G_d and to personally help that soul. It is not kosher for me to expect the world government to take my place of the place of G_d.
Posted By Mr. Jim Rook

Posted: Mar 24, 2010
Re: Where I Stand on Health Care
I read Naftalia Silberg's article regarding the recent health bill that passed by 3 [not 6] votes
As a Jew we all have an opinion.
It is important to understand how this bill was deceitfully crafted, special sweetheart deals etc and with total disdain passed against the overall disapproval [62%] of our citizens
If you truly belief that Obama will sign the executive order Stupak sold himself out for, and not reverse later, than you believe the Muslim world is pro Israel and Jews
Yes we all agree we needed health care reform. Yet when Democrats with a majority had to deal in trickery, deals behind closed doors, shamefull accounting, deceit etc etc and not include their Republicans colleagues.
Ask yourself? What is so good about the Health Care Bill, that Democrats had to payoff Democrats to get it passed? I do not know the answer and I am sure neither do you. Yes it has some good points, but the cost. This is no1 trillion dollar cost to the US tax payer, how about 2 to 3 trillion
Posted By Paul Donen, Deerfield Beach, FL


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.