HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » A Super Bowl Symposium








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment10 Comments

A Super Bowl Symposium
Join the Brainstorming Session!

It's that time of year again, when an estimated 130-140 million Americans will tune into at least part of the Big Game. An event of this enormity challenges us here at Chabad.org to provide some sort of Jewish spin.

So I called together a few people in the central office here in Brooklyn for an impromptu brainstorming session. (Considering that football is very much a team game, it's kinda appropriate that a blog post on the topic should be a team effort...) Here are the results:

The Forward Pass

Menachem Posner, a veteran member of our site's Ask the Rabbi team, recalled reading that the "forward pass," a staple of modern-day football, was not part of the original game of football. A little digging on the net on my part confirmed his memory: during the first decades of collegiate and professional football, only lateral passes were allowed. The ball could only be moved forward, past the line of scrimmage, by a player running with the ball. In 1906, the rules were changed, and the forward pass became legal. This change was implemented because many players were injured or even killed (!) while playing, due to the crush of players converging to tackle the rushers. The forward pass – originally ridiculed – opened up the game, and also allowed for spectacular 50-yard passes.

The Lesson: When trying to get the ball to the end zone, you can do it slowly and methodically, running with the ball as fast as your legs will take you—all while trying to stay clear of all the tackles seeking to throw you to the ground. Or... you can throw the ball way ahead. Life – like football – has to be a mix of both elements. Meticulous movement forward, and the occasional quantum forward pass. Even if you then get tackled, the yardage you've gained is yours to keep... (And then there's always next play.)

Game Time

The editor of our Audio and Video sections, Shmuel Lifshitz, in his youth a Bengals fan, took a few moments off his busy schedule to share this thought:

The average football game takes around three hours. That is the time that elapses from the opening kickoff till the clock runs down at the end of the fourth quarter. But how much of that is actual playing time? Around 11 minutes. Yup, zero in on the time spent between the time the ball is snapped and the moment the play is whistled dead, tally all the plays together, and you'll get around 11 minutes of action. Or around 6% of the total time.

What occupies the rest of the time? Commercials, player huddles, instant replays, commercials, timeouts, halftime, commercials, players milling around waiting for a play...

The Lesson: What's really important is not necessarily that which occupies most of our time. That half hour a day you spend studying Torah, the hour you spend with your family, the minutes you devote to prayer—that's the action. All else is just the hype that surrounds, pays for, and facilitates the action.

(Football fans: Aside for the 11 minutes of action, you too could be watching the banquet. Scroll up for the link. Even if your team is losing, this is a winning team everyone can cheer for.)

Defense or Offense?

My turn.

A while back I was at a friend's house and a football game was on. My friend kindly offered to explain the game to me. (Coming from Detroit, I have no incentive to be a football fan, and was never too versed in the game.) He explained to me that there is a "defensive line" whose members try to tackle the quarterback. And then there's the "offensive line," whose job it is to protect the quarterback against the defensive line, and prevent him from being sacked.

I was initially confused. The defensive line is on the offensive, and the offensive line is defending! I guess this is what's meant by "The best defense is offense" (and vice versa?).

The Lesson: Offense needs to incorporate defense (in which case the defense is really just camouflaged offense) and vice versa. Offense = doing good stuff; furthering our life agenda (but thankfully without risking concussions and torn hamstrings, strings that apparently only athletes possess). Defense = being on guard against unsavory influences and habits.

Put on your thinking caps and figure that one out...

Blizzards? Bah!

I'd be remiss if I didn't mention a lesson I heard from my father, Rabbi Elimelech Silberberg, a few years ago following a notoriously freezing cold football game, well, well below zero, which was nevertheless attended by around 80,000 pumped-up fans.

(Side note: My father will certainly read this blog post, as he does all the posts I write—but will likely understand very little of it. He happens to be one of those whose 6% is more like 60%, leaving little time for sports. Though he does fondly remember the Brooklyn Dodgers games he attended as a child.)

The Lesson: Go to synagogue this Shabbat. No excuses accepted. If you want to go, you will.

How to Secure a $100 Million Contract

After this article was written I sent it off to Tzvi Freeman, a.k.a. Rabbi Infinity, for editorial review. Here was what he had to add to the discussion:

Super Bowl 2008, Giants vs. Patriots. Everyone figured there's no way the Giants have a chance. No one can figure out how they got there in the first place. Yet in the fourth quarter, quarterback Eli Manning threw two touchdown passes, including the winning drive that culminated with a 13-yard touchdown to Plaxico Burress.

You can see the footage where Eli Manning has the ball in the clear in that final play. You can imagine what's going through his mind. Heart rate tops 180+. The world shifts into slow motion. He figures, "I'm in the clear. I throw the ball, we get a touchdown and the Giants win. I'm the hero of season. I get the biggest contract offered in football history."

That's when players freeze or fumble. As soon as you think of yourself as your own person, you've lost. Everything has to be the team and the game. And Manning had been fumbling a lot that season.

The Patriots have six rushers after Manning. Manning lofts a pass to the end zone where Burress catches the ball to give the Giants a lead with 35 seconds left.

At the end of the game, a reporter asked Manning, "How did you do it? How did you avoid the rush?" He replied, "I made myself small."

Manning recently was offered the biggest contract in football history.


(For two more Super Bowl ideas, see What's so Super about the Super Bowl? and Super Bowl Beer Commercials.)

Do you have any lessons or thoughts you'd like to share?


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Feb 9, 2010
Also knowing Rabbi Naftali (his father is Rabbi Silberberg) I can state that both have some recognition of the "importance" of football. It is true that the Detroit Lions are not usually anything to brag about. But equal numbers of shul members went to U-Michigan, or Michigan State. Intershul bragging does occur.

More important is to remember that there is a far distance between the lines of "one who uses each moment to the max." and a sinner. I don't believe that Rabbi Naftali means to call you a sinner because you watched (or even attended) a sporting event. A sinner has done something wrong, or neglected to fulfill an obligation. Attending, or watching a sports event doesn't mean you "sinned". But if you aim to be a tzadik, you will use your time to the max.
So what did we do? We returned from overseas on Friday, and were still jet lagged. Friend husband and I slept through the whole thing!
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI/USA
via baischabad.com

Posted: Feb 8, 2010
Andrew
I actually know that Rabbi Silberberg is a sports fan who has gone to games and loves good baseball. Please apologize.
Posted By shmuel ber

Posted: Feb 8, 2010
Simplify
I think it's much simpler. The SuperBowl is Always right around Parshat YItro. The Torah says "They Ate and Drank and Watched God".
Posted By Shlomo Schachter, Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Feb 8, 2010
Timing of the Conference
It's always, every year, scheduled for the Sunday closest to the 22 Shevat, the yahrtzeit of the Rebbe's wife.

I'm curious, Andrew, which part of the article gave you the impression that the rabbi considers sports fans sinners?
Posted By Lisa Jacobs, Cape Town, South Africa

Posted: Feb 8, 2010
Nope
No, I watched an EXCELLENT football game. One for the ages.

I've seen the exceptionally inspiring sight of groups before, and shall again, just as I have seen Niagara Falls, The Grand Canyon, and the Kotel. All are wonderful, inspiring, and shall remain so even if I occasionally do something common, fun and profane like take in a ballgame.

When G-D schedules something during the Superbowl - a Holiday, or natural event - THAT wins. When MEN do it, they could have picked another day, and have no right to be cranky. If you were to schedule a wedding on Superbowl Sunday, don't be surprised when half the invitees don't RSVP, and the other half are watching on their phones.

I sometimes wonder if folks schedule such events half to punish the 'sinners' who want to watch TV, and half so they may feel a bit sanctimonious about NOT watching TV. The Talmud says it is a sin NOT to take part in legitimate pleasures of the world. So what is wrong with enjoying a ball game?
Posted By Andrew, Denver, CO

Posted: Feb 8, 2010
Banquet Last Night
I took your advice and tuned in last night. All I have to say is... WOW!

It was so inspiring seeing the total dedication and commitment of thousands of women. And the roll call literally brought tears to my eyes.

Andrew, did you watch? I'm pretty sure that if you did, you'd see things differently.
Posted By Roberta, St. Paul, MN

Posted: Feb 7, 2010
Not at all
Worthy does NOT equal interesting. Much like attending your child's 2nd grade ballet recital, it is done out of love and duty, not because it's fun. I've attended too many of those dinners not to know the difference. If you want to pretend it is, go ahead.

Secondly, I grow tired of the frequent attempts to dismiss all secular activities or events as irrelevant or somehow wrong if they cannot be framed in terms of Torah. The games are on Sundays, they don't interfere with Sabbath services. Sports do not have to be a meaningless distraction, they can be a wonderful bonding experience.

Perhaps its just that I still feel residual annoyance at an email from my Rabbi last week urging us to attend a Nuggets basketball game to cheer an Israeli player ON THE OTHER TEAM! I am a Jew, but I am also an American and a Denverite. I'm not rooting for ANYBODY playing against my own team, for crying out loud! Some things are just for fun, and don't need a sermon. It isn't idle OR idol worship.
Posted By Andrew, Denver, CO

Posted: Feb 7, 2010
No kidding
Andrew, what the rabbi writes about 11 minutes of play time is actually from the Wall Street Journal. See http://tinyurl.com/yahcd5s.

Hmmm. Maybe you're the one who needs to do that 4 seconds of research :)

And about the convention, cheap shot!
Posted By Jared, Illinois

Posted: Feb 7, 2010
You have got to be kidding
First of all, once you eliminate the chaff of commercials and downtime between plays, there is precisely SIXTY minutes of game time. Perhaps you could have done 4 seconds of research, instead of asking some ex-Bengals fan about 11 minutes he dimly recalls from youth.

Secondly, no matter how worthy the charity, there are some activities that are so deadly dull that even G-d has to remind himself to be on his best behavior and attend. A ladies banquet 'gala' definitely falls into THAT category.

Let us not pretend that this article is anything other than yet another thinly disguised reminder that doing anything other than spending time with family or studying Torah is not as important. We know that, thank you for the patronizing moralizing. However, spending a few hours on a legitimate national ritual for fun is a legitimate pleasure, and does not need to be either justified or explained away in Jewish fashion. This article was unnecessary and rather insulting.
Posted By Andrew, Denver, CO

Posted: Feb 7, 2010
Super Bowl
The Super Bowl begets super food if you are connected right and plenty of libations.
The camaraderie of folks you may or not know is what makes it a fun thing to attend.
I don't care who wins the game, but I do hope its competitive for he sake of those who hold this game close to their heart.
I once new Benjamin....who ran a touch down for Cal to the opposite goal. He was in the clothing business. A very nice kind man was he.
Posted By sam, Castro Valley


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.