HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » The Off-Duty EMT Fiasco








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment9 Comments

The Off-Duty EMT Fiasco

Two emergency medical technicians who allegedly refused to help a pregnant woman who collapsed in the coffee shop where they were taking a break were suspended yesterday from their jobs with the New York City Fire Department.

Mayor Michael Bloomberg called their behavior inexcusable; refusing to help, he says, goes against human decency.

According to eyewitnesses, the EMTs told employees at the eatery to call 911 and then left when they were asked to help. The woman was eventually taken to a hospital, where she died a short time later. Her baby girl was too premature to survive. (Click here for the full story.)

The silver lining behind this heartrending story is that society understands that a sin of omission is no less a crime than a sin of commission. A truth that is already expressed in the Torah, in the Book of Leviticus (19:16): "Do not stand idly by when your fellow's life is threatened."

The unconscionable behavior of the EMTs is obviously exacerbated by the gravity of the situation that they ignored and the tragic consequence of their refusal to help. But in smaller ways, we all encounter situations where we are in position to help – whether we are requested to or not – and where we have the unique ability to help. But all too often we can't be bothered; we are "taking a break."

Perhaps an under-the-weather friend needs help with her children; another friend could use some valuable relationship advice; your child needs twenty minutes of quality father-son time; you know that you should really call your senator to ask her to vote yes on that pro-Israel bill...

Perhaps we are even already involved most of the day with life-saving endeavors (as were the accused EMTs), but that doesn't justify not jumping into action when presented with yet another unique opportunity to come to another's help.


Aside for its universal relevance, this thought also has a uniquely Jewish application.

Today, anyone with even minimal exposure to Jewish tradition is qualified to use the information at his/her disposal to help another, less "privileged" brother or sister. Even with a modicum of knowledge, one can positively impact another Jewish life.

As the Rebbe once said, "If you have already studied the first two letters of the aleph bet, and you have a friend who has only studied the aleph, it is your obligation to approach your friend and tell him: 'My dear Sir, I have some wonderful information to share. Aside for the aleph, there's a second letter: a bet...'"


And sometimes, the excuse for inaction can be motivated by "spiritual" reasons.

Back in the summer of 1995, I was called upon to direct a three-week day camp for mostly non-observant teenagers in a suburb of Detroit, Michigan. Though excited by the challenge, in the weeks prior to the camp's opening I was also somewhat glum. Operating this program would take hundreds of hours of my time. I would have to plan a variety of sporting events, trips, overnights, etc., and then accompany the teens throughout. If I was lucky, I could expect to keep the boys entertained for half an hour a day with some interesting Jewish topics. Aside for that, it was all about making sure that these blasé seen-and-done-everything teenagers had an amazingly fun time.

What a spiritual waste of a summer.

The camp was supposed to start on a Monday. On the Shabbat beforehand, I chanced upon a pamphlet, a weekly publication, that featured excerpts of inspiring teachings of the Rebbe. I read the following excerpt, tearfully spoken by the Rebbe on a Shabbat in October of 1953:

The soul argues, "I've taken off my cloak; how can I put it on?" (Song of Songs 5:3). I've barely managed to disrobe from the garments I was wearing—how's it now demanded of me that I put them back on?

"I've washed my feet; how can I soil them?" (ibid.). My feet, with which I tread on the ground, and are therefore soiled with [grime]—I've washed them too. And now it's demanded of me that I should once again put them on the ground—to preoccupy myself with materiality. How can I again soil them?!

Leave me alone for a while, the soul pleads. It's enough! All day... all night... all year... Let me be for a short while; for a short while leave me alone and allow me to just be alone with my Creator!

And the answer the soul receives is: No. G‑d Himself is knocking on the door, saying, "Here, behind the door is a Jewish child who knows nothing about Judaism. You must go play with him for half an hour, afterwards take a walk with him, give him candies—until eventually you'll have the opportunity to teach him the aleph bet!"

Needless to say, I was glum no more.

What are some practical ways to expose our Jewish friends and neighbors to the beauty of their heritage? I'd love to hear your thoughts—feel free to share them.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 31, 2009
First Aid and Law
At least in Canada, one may obtain a pamphlet from the police about First Aid and lawfulness.
If you are present during an accident, you are actually legally obliged to offer first aid to the best of your abilities. (That's just any citizen)
The paramedics must have been exhausted or demoralized from recent incidents, all I can imagine.
Now is the time to ask for a flyer or printout from your state or province. You just saved a life, somewhere!
Posted By sue, Kanata, ON

Posted: Dec 29, 2009
To tie a KNOT or not
As a fireman and EMT in training, it is my responsibility, even on shabbot, to use the skills G-d granted me for the benifit of another. Even if I must tie a knot to do so.
Posted By Anonymous, Denver, CO

Posted: Dec 28, 2009
Root Cause Analysis
Maybe the judgment of the EMT's behavior is premature, before an investigation. Perhaps there is information that was not apparent as to why they walked away. A root cause analysis of a problem, how come a woman died, is the method used to look for reasons a medical error occured. A sentinel event is a death caused by a medical error. A mistake happened, do not blame people, seek solutions after brainstorming causes and searching for details. For ex. Asking why? Why did the EMT's leave? Why didn't they know it was an emergency? Why didn't the people in the restaurant call 911 and tell 911 that there were EMT's in the restaurant. What happened at the hospital? It may end up that two veteran EMT's are to be reprimanded and new policies clearly written but this article did not explain all angles and may even have slandered two people. You can't believe everything that you read.
The article may have been slanderous. But the conclusions from an article as being reported facts are true.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 28, 2009
EMT ON BREAK
I ALSO see no exploitation of the woman (and her unborn baby's) death.

I had, a few months ago, a polite discussion and disagreement with a Chabad Rabbi, about a similiar situation.

The situation -- the EMT is an observant Jew. There was a situation (I forgot what) on a Shabbos. He went. Others also went; after X period of time, he was not needed any lomnger, so he returned, home.

The question then became-should he have "violated" the Shabbos, when there were others? My view-- YES, the obligation would be to save lifes, all else being secondary. The Rabbi felt since there were others who could ( And did) go, he should not have violated the Shabbos.

I rejoined- he did not know that the others would be there.

Anyhow, I repeat-I see no exploitation, for any reason.
Posted By Anonymous, Largo, FL

Posted: Dec 28, 2009
A lesson from everything
I don’t understand what people are getting so upset about.
All the author did was brought a lesson that we can learn from a tragic story.
And the author asked that if you have a better lesson to please post it.
Of course it is easy to be a critic.
If you don’t like the lesson from this story, I’m sure you can find another lesson that you can teach your self and others.
Thanks Rabbi Silberberg for the great points. After all Maimonides says to learn something positive from every situation.
Posted By nechemia deitsch, toronto, on,canada
via chabadmt.com

Posted: Dec 24, 2009
Taking the Tragedy to a Higher Level
I see no "exploitation" in this article. Quite the contrary. I see the author using this tragic situation to remind all of us of the awesome responsibilities we have to one another. A wake-up call.....

As always, the Rebbe exhorts us to be more and better than we think we can be. That's called inspirational!!

Thank you, Rabbi Silberberg, for sharing your honest disclosure and the amazing Divine Providence for you to discover your own individual mission with these youngsters.
Posted By Nacha Sara Leaf, Oak Park, MI
via baischabad.com

Posted: Dec 24, 2009
Anon in LA CA
The article does not exploit the death of Eutisha Revee. It calls it to attention and then demands of us that we prevent another such occurrance. Only then does it go on to point out that sometimes a death is not physical but rather spiritual. And even then perspective is there. I quote:
The unconscionable behavior of the EMTs is obviously exacerbated by the gravity of the situation .... But in smaller ways....

Given that Ms Revee is gone we can either ignore her death, forget her name, and learn nothing, or we can make sure to never repeat the reprehensible behavior of failing to act when action is needed. And do we wait for a life and death situation to occur? Or should we attend to all the little deaths around us?
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI/USA
via baischabad.com

Posted: Dec 23, 2009
Capitalizing on Tragedy
A pregnant woman died yesterday because two EMT technicians were "on break." And, this tragedy is then used to promote Chabad's own agenda. How cold and cruel.

That woman, who was she? Some anonymous woman. Her tragic death, a useful device to promote Chabad's agenda.

I am all for Chabad wanting uninformed Jews to learn about our heritage but I don't care for exploiting that woman's death to do so.

I would have preferred to see a discussion focused on how to prevent this kind of tragedy from happening again as well as an exploration of who this woman was.

Chabad may disdain the term 'tikun olam' but whatever you call it, we ought to each one of us take responsibility for making this world better, better for Jews and non-Jews, alike. And, that's a very Jewish notion, too!
Posted By Anonymous, L.A., CA

Posted: Dec 22, 2009
Excellent article
You might have gone to my kids camp. You might be a spark for them. We live near very few Jews and the ones we do live near are not observant. We do the best we can. We can't move. We have a nice Jewish house, keep kosher, yet we are not very observant. It is hard for us. So I thank you for helping teach my kids more than we could where we are at.
Posted By Anonymous, No Where , TX


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.