Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Views on the News » Nobel Prize or Noble Intentions?








Views on the News
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment10 Comments

Nobel Prize or Noble Intentions?

Surprise! The Norwegian Nobel Committee has awarded the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize to President Obama. Everyone was surprised, including Obama. After all, Obama had been in office less than two weeks at the time of the February 1st Nobel nomination deadline. That is not much of a chance to do anything, prize-worthy or not. The Nobel Committee explained that Obama was chosen for having "created a new climate in international politics." In effect, Obama was awarded the prize for his intentions, for announcing that he would do things differently.

Would Alfred Nobel approve of this hope-ridden method of choosing prize winners? This question – along with the question whether Obama's policies are indeed conducive for global peace – is the subject of considerable controversy.

But this all got me thinking. Does Judaism, a results-oriented way of life, allow for celebrating good intentions? The answer was not long in coming...

Just one day after Obama woke up to the news that he was a Peace Prize recipient, we observed Simchat Torah. On Simchat Torah, we celebrate two things: we celebrate that we have completed the annual cycle of the Torah reading, but we also celebrate that we are about to begin another cycle—and that it will be on an entirely different and higher level than last year's. It is not only our past accomplishments, safely locked as they are in the unchangeable past, that we can take joy from. We also fearlessly rejoice over the new path we intend to take in the future.

Foolhardy? Jumping the gun? From whence our seemingly premature confidence? Well, our Sages tell us that G‑d has confidence in our intentions too.

There's a biblical mitzvah to fast and pray when we are, G‑d forbid, in a time of peril. For example, in ancient Israel they would institute public fasts in the event of a drought. What, however, was to be done if the nature of the perilous situation precluded the possibility of fasting? Say if an enemy was poised to attack, and fasting would weaken the strength of the city's defenders? The Talmud says that in such an event, the people would pledge to fast and pray at a later date, and their intention to do so would be sufficient to evoke G‑d's mercy.

In a similar vein, the Rebbe would often quote the saying that "charity hastens the redemption." Invoking the Talmudic ruling regarding fasting, the Rebbe said on many an occasion that we need not wait to actually give the charity in order for G‑d to bring the redemption—for as soon as we resolve to do so, we are already worthy of the reward.

Okay, we already celebrated the new path we resolved to embark upon. We got the prize. Now it's time to justify the celebration, justify our confidence, justify G‑d's confidence.


Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Oct 18, 2009
Respect is more than a title. This Rabbi has shown great respect for this president by not showing all comments submitted! Respect is more than just words!
Posted By Anonymous, Woodbridge

Posted: Oct 16, 2009
Respect
First of all, with respect, I think the majority of glamour girls searching for frivolous beauty titles fall into the category of sappy whistlers in the dark. However, I note that one or two have gone on to do great things with their blithe promises.
Both Aden from Chicago and Anonymous of Fayetteville are of course quite right. It is a sad a loathsome habit - introduced by the preaching media - to drop titles and salutations.
Posted By Graham-Michael, Wellington, NZ

Posted: Oct 16, 2009
Respect and the Nobel
Interesting additional point. In these politically fractious times, if President Obama can teach us all to treat each other with courtesy and respect, regardless of our views, that alone will be worth a Nobel Peace Prize!
Posted By Anonymous, Fayetteville

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
Respect.
Thank you for a balanced piece and also a reminder that good intentions do have value.

I would, however, like to point out that your habit of referring to the President as "Obama" comes across a little bit disrespectful. Protocol would have you refer to him as President Obama the first time you refer to him in a piece, and as Mr. Obama in subsequent references. Showing respect for the office of the President does not imply that you agree with him, it shows that you were raised right.

It would be very discourteous if someone referred to the Rebbe, z'l, as "Schneerson", would it not?
Posted By Aden, Chicago, IL
via chabaduchicago.com

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
good intentions
Perhaps then, all Miss America contestants, along with every political candidate, should be awarded a Nobel Prize, because they all announce how they want to eradicate world hunger, end war, help the poor,etc. It's not enough to have "good" intentions; they must be followed by "good" actions and "good" results. I'm sure many leaders we would consider evil believed their intentions were good - and many of their followers believed as well.
Posted By Sarah, San Antonio, TX

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
An optimist isn't necessarily a blithe, sappy whistler in the dark. To be hopeful in bad times is not just foolishly romantic. If we remember those times and places where people have behaved magnificently, this gives us energy to act and at least the possibility of sending this spinning top of a world in a different direction.
Posted By Graham-Michael, Wellington, NZ

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
Past and future
Thanks for a good and balanced perspective on this. Though I am an Obama supporter, I tended to agree that the Nobel was a bit premature. This helps me reconcile things a bit. Perhaps in this case, the Nobel serves as less than an award for past work but as a fellowship/grant to encourage future, greater work.
Posted By Susan, Fayetteville, NC

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
not procrastination?
Thanks for those words. Many times I say I will do and i mean them (especially making up for past transgressions) but times do not always allow for the make up. Especially financial. As long as I know i am not just procrastinating it is good to know that G-d waits patiently. After all, everything happens for a reason. It is finding the good in it all that can be hard.
Posted By Norm S., Orlando, fl

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
Intention or fantasy?
How do you know that Obama intends to strive for peace? Peace at what price? Peace among whom? When?

Words are empty. Only Obama and G-d know the truth. I believe it was foolhardy of the Nobel Committee to award the prize on possible intentions.
Posted By Marie-Anne Harkness, Auburn, WA

Posted: Oct 15, 2009
Peace Prize
Thank you for succinct comment. This has greatly supported - and sorted - my own thinking. In G-d is our hope, and if Mr Obama can help push us in that direction, then blessings on him.
Posted By Graham-Michael, Wellington, NZ


 



By Naftali Silberberg   More by this authors...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.