HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ideas & Beliefs
 
Chabad.org » Ideas & Beliefs » Battle of Minds » Is Beauty Truth? » Answer #7


Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
4 Comments Posted
Battle of Minds


Is Beauty Truth?
If something is beautiful, is it true? Is a beautiful symphony as true as a scientific fact?

Chana Silberstein, educational psychologist Michael Katzenelson, physicist Tzvi Freeman, writer Nachshon Zohari, psychotherapist Alexander Poltorak, physicist Yaakov Ort, editor, activist Aryeh Gotfryd, applied ecologist All other answers
 

Aryeh Gotfryd, applied ecologist
Read Bio
Aryeh Gotfryd, applied ecologist

I am not a Kabbalist. Nor a philosopher.

If I were, I could speak about such sublime realities like beauty and truth in something approaching an authoritative fashion. But all I can muster is a few life lessons and some Torah gleanings.

For instance. Sometimes truth is ugly.

Take Abraham for example. Here is a man who is everybody's hero. Who else could be adored by Christian, Muslim and Jew? Founder of ethical monotheism, host par excellence, educator, iconoclast, at once challenging men to rise above their mediocrity, yet challenging G-d to descend from His uncompromising excellence and value us for who we are.

Yes, Abraham was beautiful, but he didn't stop there. His commitment went far beyond his natural goodness, far beyond his kind and wise nature. His commitment was ultimate, and that can look scary, very scary.

Abraham's biggest test, the binding of Isaac, is not the kind of deed one calls wise, or kind, or sane for that matter. I recall studying the story of the binding of Isaac with a brilliant scholar who loved nothing more than Torah. But this story bugged him, no, actually haunted him. "He was wrong! He had no right to do it!" The story drove him nuts.

Abraham built his entire life on promoting G-d in the world. He weaned the Middle East off of idolatry, taught people, fed them, nurtured their faith in an all- knowing, just and benevolent Creator. He was a living model of the good G-d he preached. And then what?

Then came his big test: To offer up Isaac as a sacrifice. Which sounds a lot like this: Commit murder. Kill a human being. Kill your own son. Your only son. The one you love. The promised father-to- be of your millions of children. Go ahead. Make me a liar. Tie him up and slit his throat. Watch him bleed to death. Trash your life, trash My reputation, and don't ask why. Just do it.

Ahh, you may recall, recoil. It wasn't so bad. At the last moment, G-d said "Stop". He just wanted the offer, not the deed. Yes, G-d was beautiful, but Abraham did not want to stop there. "Let me take just a drop of blood." Abraham wanted to serve in truth, ultimate truth. And that ain't pretty.

But then again, I'm not a philosopher, nor a Kabbalist.

If I were, I might see the beauty within the ugliness, the truth within the lie. But guess what. I can't. All I know is "G-d said so." And in truth, that's enough, because ironically, living in truth with G-d IS beautiful, whether we understand it or not.

Close Full Answer
4 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Discussion
Latest Comments:
Posted: Aug 24, 2009
Re: Anonymous, Crestview, FL
I cannot help but think that Abraham although revered as the an important figure for many, would have gone ahead killing Isaac knowing well that killing was wrong owing to his belief in G-d. Abraham would have done it neverthelessly & knowingly despite the insanity of it! Maybe faith taken to an extreme is insane as this & should be guarded against.
Abraham had G-d stopping him but what can can be said of ourselves in our daily life? It shows human imperfectness, an ugly side of human being! Blind faith is not beauty or truth as G-d taught Abraham the hard way!
Goodness when it can be felt, known, derived, realized etc is not disobedience to G-d instead it is G-dliness itself!
Posted By Man in the Mirror

Posted: Sep 6, 2008
But it would not be beautiful....
If Abraham had in fact been insane, and it were not G-d He was obeying, but his own conception of G-d. And that is where we recoil; the fear that someone might somehow think G-d is telling them to do the same thing but it would not in fact be Him. However, in this moment of divine convergence, the beauty was that it truly WAS G-d, and Abraham was aware enough to know it - and follow.
Posted By Heather, Lancaster, pa

Posted: Feb 20, 2008
Deeper meaning
Abraham, knew G-d's voice, Abraham, feared G-d, knew that he had to do whatever G-d asked him to do, without question, Abraham, learned to trust with obediance. G-d says that HE wants our obediance more than our sacrifice. In that time era human sacrifice was practiced, as I understand it, G-d wanted Abraham, to know that human sacrifice was not a choice that the true G-d had choosen for His people. Abraham, had to learn to see with the eyes of faith, and not with human sight. I believe, it goes much deeper than human reasoning. Abraham's spiritual encounter with the Creator of heaven and earth and knowing HIS voice lead Abraham to love his G-d with all his heart, with all his soul, and with his might and that was put in Abraham's heart by G-d so we too can start seeking and loving more the Creator than the creation.
Posted By josie, Scottsdale, AZ

 

 
Subscribe
 

Ask the Rabbi
Got questions?
Searching for meaning?
Ask the Rabbi

Question of the Week
Read the Question of the Week

Ask the Rabbi
Browse Archives

Woman to Woman
Read More

Knowledge Base